Includes MASSIVE SPOILERS for Dune: Prophecy season 1!
Tula Harkonnen lied about having a child in Dune: Prophecy flashbacks to the first season, and there are a few important reasons for that. Set 10,000 years before the rise of Paul Atreides in Dune In the timeline, the HBO prequel series examines many of the major factions and houses in the early stages of their development. Long before the Bene Gesserit was an extremely powerful organization with deep-rooted influence throughout the Known Universe, it was the Brotherhood, led by Mother Superior Valya Harkonnen.
Actresses Olivia Williams and Emily Canning play Tula Harkonnen in Dune: Prophecy cast, allowing the audience to examine Valya's sister at different points in her life. Tula is committed to the Brotherhood and her sister's cause, but there is an important conflicting aspect to her this sets up much of his arc in the first season. She has committed extreme acts, such as the atrocity against House Atreides, but is ultimately less ambitious than Valya, who strives for power and control above all else. This led Tula to hide a big secret from her sister.
Tula made Valya believe that her baby died in the dunes: prophecy
Tula gave Desmond as a baby
Desmond Hart is the main antagonist of Dune: Prophecy first season, but the HBO series makes it clear from the beginning that there is much more to the character than meets the eye. The end of episode 5 finally reveals its origin, with Tula using the Brotherhood's banned Thinking Machine technology to access its genetic history, examining its DNA and connecting it to Houses Harkonnen and Atreides. Tula then realizes that he is her baby, who she conceived with Orry Atreides before joining the Brotherhood previous decades.
Desmond Hart believes his mother cast him aside, choosing the Brotherhood over him. However, episode 6's flashbacks reveal that Tula desperately wanted to keep him, but instead exchanged him for someone else's baby with the help of Francesca. Tula then told Valya that she had lost her son at birth. Valya is sad, mainly because she was excited about the prospect of a Harkonnen-Atreides child and his genetic potential, which could be used in the Brotherhood's schemes. This was precisely why Tula was apprehensive.
What Really Happened to Tula's Son After He Was Born
Desmond lived a hard life and became a soldier
Tula Harkonnen's son was switched to a different family at birth. Tula believed she was handing him over to a kind, loving family so he could have a decent life away from Brotherhood politics, but this was the opposite of what happened to Desmond. Desmond Hart lived a terrible life, becoming bitter towards the Brotherhood and his mother for getting rid of him and leaving him to fend for himself. He became a survivor, managing to serve twelve missions as a soldier on Arrakis.while most wouldn't even be able to pass one.
His first action was to kill Pruwet Richese, interrupting the planned wedding and killing his sister Kasha, one of Valya's longtime supporters.
On Desmond's last trip, he was the only survivor of an attack orchestrated by the Brotherhood and was swallowed by a sandworm. His body was recovered by an unknown assailant and a Thinking Machine was implanted in his eye. With his long-standing distaste for the Brotherhood refueled by the recent attack on him and his men, Desmond Hart was the perfect candidate to be used as a weapon against the organization and its conspiracies. His first action was to kill Pruwet Richese, interrupting the planned wedding and killing his sister Kasha, one of Valya's longtime supporters.
Why did Tula keep her son from Valya and the brotherhood
Tula did not want to subject her son to Valya's control
It should be mentioned first that Tula Harkonnen is loyal to Valya, as she swore the oath by the Voice's ultimatum in the flashbacks of episode 6. However, there are certain limits that even the most dedicated sisters cannot cross. Sister Francesca refuses to kill Javicco Corrino despite Valya's orders, just as Tula hides her son from Valya and sends him away. Tula does not want her son to be part of the Brotherhood's plots, as she knows it will mean depriving the boy of any autonomy. and chance for normality.
As Valya explains to Javicco, the Brotherhood's control runs deep, and the emperor, despite his title, has never made a choice of his own in his entire life. Javicco is the prime example of what Desmond Hart's life would have been like if he had remained with Tula, never fully in control of his own destiny. Tula believes in the Brotherhood in Dune: Prophecy and is willing to subject her own life to Valya's whims, but she draws the line at subjugating her son to the same fate.