Anakin skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi are two from Star Wars' Extra highly effective and two Star Wars' Finest characters - However who was actually extra expert? Anakin/Darth Vader and Obi-Wan have had a number of clashes in Star Wars motion pictures and TV reveals, together with in Star Wars: Episode III - Sith RevengeLike this, A brand new hopeand Obi-Wan Kenobi. Anakin/Vader's energy and brute energy are simple, particularly since he's chosen, however Obi-Wan virtually all the time comes out on prime.
Obi-Wan clearly beat Vader in Sith's RevengeSince he left him virtually useless, a lot in order that he actually believed Anakin was useless after Mustafar. In Obi-Wan KenobiVader overcame Obi-Wan initially, however ultimately, he was defeated by Obi-Wan as soon as once more. Even in A brand new hopeVader actually doesn't kill Obi-Wan; Obi-Wan turns into one with the energy earlier than being knocked down. With the gross energy of Anakin and the file of very constant victories of Obi-Wan, the query stays: Who was most expert between Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader?
Anakin was undeniably extra highly effective - however energy will not be the identical because the ability
As chosen, Anakin had immense gross energy
Anakin Skywalker was not solely one of the crucial highly effective Jedi, but in addition, like Darth Vader, he grew to become one of many Star Wars' Sith extra highly effective. Though Obi-Wan could have been robust in energy by itself, he definitely doesn't defeat Anakin/Vader when it comes to energy. Power doesn't robotically equal to ability, though. Whereas Anakin could have an Obi-Wan beat when it comes to energy, Obi-Wan was all the time extra expert than Anakin.
Partly, this may increasingly have been because of the second of Anakin's fall to the darkish facet. Sure, Anakin had accomplished his Jedi coaching when he grew to become Darth Vader, however Obi-Wan had much more years in his belt like Jedi. After Anakin grew to become Darth Vader, his expertise have additionally modified if they aren't fully stopped due to the constraints of their course of. Vader clearly continued to be a formidable opponent, however needed to adapt to Vader's restrictive and painful costume.
Whereas Anakin could have an Obi-Wan beat when it comes to energy, Obi-Wan was all the time extra expert than Anakin.
Obi-Wan Kenobi was extra disciplined
Obi-Wan Kenobi was identified to be a dependable and steadiness
Even with extra time from Obi-Wan as Jedi, apart, Obi-Wan was merely extra disciplined than Anakin when it comes to character. Whereas Anakin was in love and would act first and would assume later, Obi-Wan was virtually all the time calm, rational and centered. In reality, he was identified within the Jedi order for his self-discipline and knowledge, with even different members of the Jedi Council in search of solutions generally.
This dynamic was clear with former Obi-Wan Jedi Grasp Qui-Gon Jinn. Qui-Gon's nature was way more like Anakin than Obi-Wan's, and he was typically cussed and prepared to interrupt the principles if he felt it was the suitable factor to do. Then again, Obi-Wan was devoted to the Jedi method. Though this doesn't essentially imply the next degree of ability in Obi-Wan, as he was capable of stay centered and devoted to growing his expertise and trusting the energy.
Obi-Wan's Mild Saber expertise and the preventing model have been greater than Anakin's
As a result of he was extra disciplined, Obi-Wan was the most effective duelist
This self-discipline that Obi-Wan had translated immediately along with his expertise with a light-weight and battle. Fairly often, Anakin went forward in a battle with no clear plan, which led to his seize greater than as soon as and was the rationale he misplaced his hand to inform Dooku. The identical occurred along with his battle with Obi-Wan Kenobi in Mustafar. Obi-Wan explicitly warned Anakin in order to not attempt to soar when Obi-Wan had a excessive floor. Anakin was, in his personal phrases, unable to be rational, nevertheless, and it value her all remaining member and virtually her life.
The extent and Obi-Wan's potential in battle are, in flip, why he was capable of defeat Darth Maul in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace Earlier than he was actually a Jedi in full proper. They're additionally why he defeated Normal Grievous and Anakin/Vader alone in Sith's Revenge. In all three circumstances, extra than simply gross energy (though Obi-Wan had a whole lot of it as nicely), Obi-Wan was strategic, which was an essential think about his victory.
Obi-Wan was strategic, which was an essential think about his victory.
Additionally it is exceptional that the duel of the locations battle in The Ghost Risk And the Battle of Mustafar in Sith's Revenge They're thought-about two Star Wars' Finest gentle saber duels. Each battles concerned Obi-Wan, suggesting that their lightsaber expertise are higher than most. Clearly, gentle saber expertise should not the one essential expertise. Star Wars.
Anakin was expert in sure methods, however he was by no means extra expert than Obi-Wan
Anakin was an incredible pilot and had different expertise
Obi-Wan had no benefit in all Jedi/Drive expertise. Anakin was unquestionably the most effective pilot, for instance, and he had dominated some superb powers that Obi-Wan by no means appears to have had, even when he was capable of switch the essence of his daughter's remaining life to Ahsoka within the mortis gods arc in Star Wars: The Clone Wars. On this sense, there isn't any direct reply.
There was additionally some speech on how Star Wars Measures coaching and ability. In YouTube Channel Star Wars principle, visitor Nick Gillard defined that, in his opinion, George Lucas imagined a scale of 10 - though nobody hit 10. With coaching, somebody might transfer on this scale. Nevertheless, as has lengthy been demonstrated in Star Wars on the darkish facet of the impression of power on energy, The darkish facet would robotically advance somebody over this scale.
Based mostly on this scale, Anakin and Obi-Wan would have been a bit the identical when it comes to ability throughout their Mustafar battle, every touchdown someplace in about 9. The restrictions on the darkish facet have been nonetheless at stake. Anakin could have gotten this impulse, however he was nonetheless performing from a spot of hatred, anger and aggression that diminished his rationality, inflicting him to make silly actions just like the soar towards Obi-Wan when he had the excessive floor.
Anakin could have elevated this impulse, however he was nonetheless performing from a spot of hatred, anger and aggression that diminished his rationality.
Comparisons between Obi-Wan and Anakin, finally Star Wars. Anakin had immense energy, particularly when he joined the darkish facet (earlier than he wanted the Darth Vader costume), however Obi-Wan stays one of the crucial disciplined Jedi in all Star Wars. Even so, Obi-Wan Kenobi remained extra certified than Anakin skywalkermade clear by their constant victories.