Severus Snape is usually accused of being overly obsessive about Lily Potter in Harry Potterhowever two particulars in his story recommend that he's judged considerably unfairly. In fact, it could't be denied that Snape is bother. He handled Harry terribly all through the collection, all due to his personal emotional immaturity. Nonetheless, claims that Snape was a stalker could also be taking issues too far. He was a Loss of life Eater who maintained a love for his childhood good friend, however proof signifies that Snape accepted that he and Lily have been on two totally different paths in historical past. Harry Potter.
The large reveal that Snape and Lily have been pals was made for an emotional second in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It out of the blue made sense why Dumbledore had trusted Snape all these years, and it was clear that the previous Loss of life Eater had actually been making an attempt to guard Harry all alongside. Snape's true intentions and love for Lily have been important within the emotional ending of Harry Potter. But, the general public grew to become essential of Snape's intentions through the years. A few of his conduct raised purple flags, however there are some particulars which might be usually neglected when judging his character.
Snape by no means gave Lily a love potion in Harry Potter
Snape proved he wasn't like Merope Gaunt
Snape was a potions prodigy, which implies that brewing a love potion and giving it to Lily would have been straightforward to do - however he by no means did. He may have rapidly ended Lily and James' relationship, however there's no indication Harry Potter that such a factor has ever crossed your thoughts. In fact, Snape shouldn't be celebrated simply because he by no means drugged his childhood crush. But, the truth that Snape by no means adopted this path has thematic worth contained in the Harry Potter collection.
A major facet of Lord Voldemort's story is that his mom, Merope Gaunt, used a Love Potion to get the person she was obsessive about to marry her. It was via this methodology that Merope and Tom Riddle Sr conceived their baby. Voldemort's mom was abused and uncared for, and this made her so determined for love that she resorted to excessive and morally despicable strategies to get it. Snape has an identical story to Merope. He grew up in a loveless house, however regardless of his expertise with potions, Snape by no means resorted to the identical strategies as Merope.
Snape didn't know that Trelawney's prophecy may connect with Lily's son
Snape clearly wasn't controlling Lily's life and household
Along with respecting Lily's proper to decide on it or not, there are extra indications in Harry Potter collection that Snape wasn't obsessive about and pursued his childhood good friend. After the pair ended their friendship on the finish of their fifth 12 months, Snape and Lily accomplished their remaining two years at Hogwarts and entered the wizarding world as adults. Snape grew to become a Loss of life Eater, and Lily married James Potter, had a son, and joined the Order of the Phoenix. It's usually assumed that Snape maintained management over Lily throughout this, however there may be proof to recommend in any other case.
As a low-ranking Loss of life Eater, Snape was wanting to impress Lord Voldemort. So when he heard Sybill Trelawney make a prophecy close to the start of 1980, he rapidly handed it on to his grasp. Snape didn't hear every little thing, however he reported to Voldemort {that a} boy, born in late July to folks who had defied the Darkish Lord 3 times, can be the villain's undoing.. Snape instantly regretted telling Voldemort this when he discovered that the prophecy may apply to Lily Potter and her son.
As soon as he discovered that Lily had a son who match the prophecy, Snape rapidly started to again away.
The truth that Snape didn't know that Lily's household matched Trelawney's prophecy implies that he wasn't maintaining a tally of his childhood good friend. This is sensible, because it was Snape himself who primarily ended the connection. Lily demanded that he select between their friendship and his aspiration to turn into a Loss of life Eater, and he selected the latter. He appeared so absorbed in his objective that he didn't take into account how Lily might be caught within the center. As soon as he discovered that Lily had a son who match the prophecy, Snape rapidly started to again away.
Snape was bother, however he wasn't an obsessive stalker
Snape wasn't good, however his love was real
It can't be denied that Snape was troubled. Your conduct in Harry Potter it was actually atrocious. Even after realizing that Voldemort would goal Lily due to his info, Snape tried to discount just for her life – not that of her son or husband. The Loss of life Eater solely agreed to guard the Potters as an entire when it grew to become clear that this was the one means Dumbledore may assist him. But, saying Snape was obsessive about Lily or stalked her is unfair. As a substitute, the proof factors to the truth that he tried to overlook her fully earlier than his loss of life.
Harry Potter spends a big period of time exploring the distinction between love and obsession.
Snape selected the Darkish Arts over his friendship with Lily, leading to his outdated good friend's loss of life. This was eye-opening for Snape. He had by no means skilled a mom's love, so the truth that Lily sacrificed her life for her son was one thing he by no means thought to foresee. Harry Potter spends a big period of time exploring the distinction between love and obsession. In fact, Snape was nonetheless an immature, emotional, merciless messhowever the particulars of his story show that his complicated emotions for Lily tended extra towards real love.