This principle proves that the Storm of Onyx fully missed the primary fascinating villain within the Empyrean collection

Warning: Spoilers for Onyx Storm

Sarah J. Maas' Onyx Storm generated quite a few fan theories, and certainly one of them, even when not true, reveals how dangerous the EMPYREAN SERIES Wasted his first actually fascinating villain. Onyx Storm And its cliffhanger finish was full of recent locations, new folklore and new characters. This included Theophanie, a brand new Venin antagonist who appeared ready to develop into the good evil of the collection Advancing.

Sadly, apparently this isn't the case, as Theophanie was killed within the local weather battle of the guide. As such, Onyx StormThe ending raised extra questions than it answered, together with how Theophanie appeared to know quite a bit about Violet, as a result of she was so determined to coach Violet, as Andnderna thought-about her plans and way more. Nonetheless, a brand new Onyx Storm Idea means that Theophanie actually has a lot deeper ties with violet than ever, and is tragic and convincing.

The speculation postulates Theophanie was in love with Asher Sorrengail

Makes a wierd quantity of that means

The speculation, which was first revealed in Reddit, however has since been excluded, postulates that Venin Theophanie has met and fell in love with Asher Sorrengail sooner or later prior to now. It's not loopy to assume that this principle additionally has some benefit. A big a part of Onyx Storm 'The plot concerned Violet and his staff touring to the islands on the coast of Navarre, following the footsteps of his father, who typically traveled to the islands, to trace his diaries.

Whereas all islands like Zehyllna play a task in Onyx StormUnnbriel is of specific significance: not solely Asher traveled there, but in addition introduced Violet there when she was only a little one to dedicate to the goddess, Dunne, within the temple of Dunne. It's not clear precisely why he did it, however we all know Lilith wasn't blissful about it, that Violet didn't full her dedication (therefore her hair simply standing out) and had one thing to do with Violet being sick. Whether or not it's your unnamed Ehlers-Danlos syndrome or another illness, it appears that evidently Asher had her purpose to take her daughter to the temple of Dunne. We additionally know that in his previous Theophanie was a priestess of the Dunne Temple on Unnbriel Island.

Suits Theophanie's hatred by Lilith Sorrengail in a brand new gentle

She noticed Lilith as a contest in two methods

It's not prefer to assume that sooner or later in his journeys, Asher met Theophanie and the priestess fell in love with him. Maybe studying that Asher was in love with Lilith, and even merely being refused earlier than that, is why she left her service as a temple priest and turned Venin. He will surely clarify his hatred poison by Lilith Sorrengail. This hatred appeared merely resulting from the truth that Theophanie noticed the overall as a contest; It might be assumed that she and Lilith had collided in the course of the battles and Venin's enmity grew from these clashes.

Nonetheless, in the course of the closing battle of Onyx StormViolet abruptly realizes that Theophanie is just not a bearer of lightning like her, however that her signet is wielding to the storm, similar to Lilith. "She is the reply to my mom"She tells Bodhi, to which an indignant theophanie whistle,"She was the reply to Me. "Once more, for the time being, it learn like theophanie's satisfaction merely rearing it. Placing it within the context of theophanie having love however him marrying and love lilith, Nonetheless, Abruptly, These Phrases Tackle a Deeper Mening. Theophanie's Seething Hatred of Lilith and the Truth She Sems to Know A Lot Extra About Violet and the Sorngail Household Than She Ought to Themselves: She Knew Asher A Lengthy Time Aug. And She Love Him.

Why the Tempest Idea of Teophanie Onyx might not work

She might be very outdated for the timeline to align herself

That mentioned, though the idea that Theophanie liked Asher is admittedly fascinating and would clarify quite a bit, there's a approach that it is mindless. We have no idea how outdated theofanie has or how lengthy it's in Venin, however the context of Onyx Storm It makes it appear to be she is outdated Previous man, too outdated to have been up to date with Asher Sorrengail. Though her precise age is just not declared, there's a feeling that she is a minimum of just a few hundred years outdated and, if that is so, then the idea clearly doesn't work, as defined in Onyx Storm That Venin doesn't really feel love - not the way in which people do, in any case. It's unlikely that if Theophanie had been a venin when she crossed with Asher, she would have fallen in love with a weak human.

Then again, this solely provides credibility to the opposite common principle of followers that Asher Sorrengail No human, however venin - and is, actually, the smart, whose title was revealed as Berwyn in Onyx Storm. This might clarify why Theophanie is so aggressive with the smart; The hatred that robust normally derives solely from annoyed love - or what goes on for love for Venin. There may be nonetheless a lot thriller in regards to the historical past of Asher Sorrengail, his travels, how he died and why. It's not as if there isn't a precedent within the EMPYREAN SERIES Books for a Sorngail member of the family pretending to his personal loss of life in any case. So whereas Theophanie's age and the timeline don't appear to extend to help the idea that she liked Asher, they don't refute her both.

This proves how wealthy Theophanie's story may very well be (and the way was she wasted)

She was killed very early

Whether or not the idea was confirmed or not, it nonetheless takes house as Theophanie has been wasted, and it's a pity. Onyx Storm He simply touched her background story that there was way more for her than discovering her eyes. Sadly, Theophanie was killed with out ceremony, simply because the guide advised that there was a fancy and engaging story behind her. It's a recurring sample within the EMPYREAN SERIES - The characters are killed once they begin to get fascinating (or are already useless), and we have now not realized something about them or simply find out about them posthumously. Asher Sorrengail. Lilith Sorrengail. NAILIN. Liam Mairi. Now Theophanie.

It's a pity too, as a result of there's a lot to discover with Theophanie's story, and it has been advised that she has a reference to Violet's midfielder in Dunne's temple. Giving up your priest remains to be clearly a painful topic to her even after years. This bothers her, bothers you -enough to get her away from her recreation in the course of the closing combat with Violet and divulges an emotion that isn't simply the calculation of a venin, the boiling fury or the provocation:

"I've my subsequent assault when it seems a half meter forward. 'Inform me, do you miss Unnbriel?'

Her eyes shine, and she or he scares.

Victory. It recovers increasingly more energy, wrapping it as a melted wire. - Don't you yearn for Temple? I take advantage of the phrases that the excessive priestess had in me.

His face spins with an emotion that nearly appears anxious, however is shortly masked with anger. 'You?' She distinction. - Or are you immune, having been performed solely however not devoted? She accuses. "Are you aware the ache of by no means being allowed to return, to know that it might minimize the identical factor that stored me untouchable all these years?" ""

Onyx Storm - p. 737

With this alternate, Theophanie raised every part we thought we knew about Venin's emotional panorama, which had been described in EMPYREAN SERIES The right way to function nearly as psychopaths, feeling nothing to others exterior the calculation and the way to obtain their ends. A venin that longs for the temple and brazenly acknowledges that it makes its deep ache minimize is virtually unprecedented. This results in the query: If this little data about Venin is improper, then what else the folks of Navarre is improper? Or perhaps Theophanie was an anomaly, nonetheless in a position to really feel human feelings after years. And if that is so, it's completely attainable that it was additionally in a position to really feel some type of love.

The Empyrean collection wants higher and extra developed villains

It's a huge downside three books in

However Theophanie's life being interrupted in Onyx Storm It's not simply irritating due to the way in which you ran over your fascinating private story. The largest query is that Theophanie was the primary actually fascinating villain EMPYREAN SERIES Had and three books in, this can be a huge downside. The venin has been primarily a faceless and faceless horde, apart from the smart, which solely appeared briefly scenes in battle that exposed nothing about him earlier than being apparently killed by Xaden. We now know that he's probably not useless, nevertheless it's not like this revelation made him extra fascinating. It's nonetheless a clean determine, for essentially the most half.

Human antagonists within the books had been additionally extremely one -dimensional, just because their antagonism about Violet has been so exaggerated and comically exaggerated that they didn't have layers or subtlety as characters. Jack Barlowe merely determined that he hated Violet in sight and struggled to be sadistic, and Bastgiat's main villains, similar to Colonel Aetos and Commander Varrish, are principally interchangeable in his corrupted evil.

Simplifying, the villains of EMPYREAN SERIES he was tedious. None of his motivations was explored past a very simplistic "I wish to energy."They aren't eradicated and, as such, solely serve the plot with out including any actual shade or wealth to the story. Killing Theophanie, the one villain within the collection that confirmed her greater than it appeared that, who had dedicated and complex motivations, was an extremely silly transfer on Sarah J. Maas. Onyx Storm I might reveal that she is just not useless in any case. However with a collection that has already acquired a lot disaster for repeating the identical tales and twists within the plot, that will be an issue by itself.