The latest revelation about Desmond Hart in Dune: Prophecy probably confirms that the biggest theory about the character is not true. The story of Dune: Prophecy is set 10,000 years before the Dune films, and follows several ancestors of the Atreides and Harkonnen who appear in the films. Of all the characters in Dune: ProphecyDesmond Hart has been the most mysterious. After appearing in the Emperor's palace in the first episode of the series and revealing that he survived being swallowed by a sandworm, many questions were left unanswered about Desmond Hart.
Dune: Prophecy It mainly follows Valya Harkonnen, who leads the Bene Gesserit and is planning to have complete control over the Empire. Throughout the series, Desmond Hart has been one of Valya's main enemies, but it's never been clear exactly why he has such disdain for her sisterhood.. However, the end of Dune: Prophecy episode 5 revealed that Desmond may actually be the abandoned son of Vayla's sister Tula. The shocking revelation that Desmond Hart is half Harkonnen and half Atreides suggests that the most popular theory about who he really is is probably wrong.
Dune: Prophecy Theory That Suggests Desmond Hart Is a Ghola Explained
Desmond Hart could be an artificially created clone in Dune: Prophecy
It has yet to be explained how Desmond Hart survived the sandworm attack on Arrakis, but one popular theory is that the Desmond viewers are currently watching is actually a copy of the famous warrior. Node Dune universe, gholas are humans artificially created from a cell of someone who died. Desmond Hart being a ghola would explain how he apparently survived being swallowed by a sandworm and learned his mysterious power that is seen throughout. Dune: Prophecy.
There are several moments when Dune: Prophecy supporting the theory that Desmond Hart is a gholalike when he resisted Valya by using the Voice on him in episode 2 of the series. As Valya has always been able to use the Voice on her enemies, Desmond resisting was shocking, and there has to be some sort of explanation as to how he was able to do this. Furthermore, Desmond Hart has always been obsessed with Thinking Machines. Dune: Prophecywhich suggests he may be linked to them in some way.
Desmond Hart's Harkonnen/Atreides Revealed in Dune: Prophecy Suggests Robot Theory Isn't True
Desmond Hart being Harkonnen and Atreides is shocking enough
While the theory that Desmond Hart is a ghola was very intriguing and could have led to some compelling moments in the Dune: Prophecylike the reveal of who created the new version of him, Desmond being a Harkonnen and an Atreides is much more interesting. The flashback in Dune: Prophecy episode 3 showed that Tula murdered almost every member of House Atreides. However, this was after she had already slept with her boyfriend, Orry Atreides. Therefore, the end of Dune: Prophecy will likely reveal how and why she decided to abandon her and Orry's son.
Desmond being revealed as a ghola would be a twist within a twist and could end up making the character very complicated.
The end of Dune: Prophecy will likely spend a significant amount of time focusing on the relationship between Desmond and Tula. Therefore, it is unlikely that Desmond will also be revealed as a ghola. Desmond being revealed as a ghola would be a twist within a twist and could end up making the character very complicated. Desmond being part Harkonnen and having a grudge against his family members who abandoned him is a much more interesting story to explore than him being an artificially created ghola.and should be the main focus Dune: Prophecy end.
Why Desmond Hart's Revelation Doesn't Completely Ruin Dune: Prophecy Theory
Desmond Hart is still a very mysterious character in Dune: Prophecy
The reveal that Desmond Hart is Harkonnen and Atreides still doesn't answer how he survived being swallowed by the sandworm. Therefore, There's still a chance Desmond could be a ghola in Dune: Prophecy. It's possible that Desmond Hart was created by a group that wants to use his powerful bloodline to take control of the Empire. In Dune According to lore, the gholas were created almost exclusively by a group of genetically altered humans known as the Bene Tleilax.
The introduction of the Bene Tleilax would further expand the world of Duneand could potentially lead to more seasons of Dune: Prophecy or other spin-offs. In addition to the Bene Tleilax, the Bene Gesserit also created at least one ghola in Dune tradition, which means they may have a special interest in Desmond Hart that goes beyond his connection to Tula. The revelation that Desmond is a ghola would open up many possibilities for Dune: Prophecy or other projects within the franchise. So it's entirely possible that Desmond will still be revealed to be an artificially created ghola.
There are still many mysteries surrounding Desmond Hart
The Finale Of Dune: Prophecy Will Reveal A Lot About Desmond Hart
Even though there is only one episode left in Dune: Prophecythere are still many unanswered questions about Desmond Hart. Over the course of the series, he has achieved a powerful position and enjoys the support of the Emperor and Empress. In Dune: Prophecy episode 5, Desmond has been hunting down members of the rebellion to protect House Corrino, but it has not yet been revealed what his true intentions are.. It is unclear whether he wishes to simply serve Emperor Corrino or rule the Empire himself.
There have been hints that Desmond is also somehow connected to Shai-Hulud, the One God who the Fremen believe created and ruled the entire universe.
Being swallowed by a sandworm clearly changed Desmond Hart's perspective on the Empire in a major waythen the end of Dune: Prophecy will likely reveal what your exact experience on Arrakis was. There have been hints that Desmond is also somehow connected to Shai-Hulud, the One God who the Fremen believe created and ruled the entire universe. Therefore, it is possible that Shai-Hulud set Desmond on a specific path and tasked him with a goal that could be revealed at the end of Dune: Prophecy.