The new prequel series, Dune: Prophecyintroduced a replacement for Jason Momoa’s Duncan Idaho character, but there’s a notable twist to it. Idaho was featured in Frank Herbert’s original Dune romance as the loyal swordmaster of House Atreides. The climax of the 2021 film adaptation saw Jason Momoa’s iteration of Paul Atreides and Lady Jessica, solidifying him as one of the franchise’s heroes. But his absence left a notable void in 2024 Dune: Part Twohow, even though he is the best Dune The film lacks a lot of humor.
Of course, Stilgar adds some comedy to Dune: Part Twoand that’s not it Dune It needs to be a comedy. However, having a little the lightness to balance the intense lore and thematic exploration can make the world feel more lived-in. Jason Momoa and Timothée Chalamet had excellent chemistry in the first film, and there’s nothing like it in the new one series so far. The HBO prequel is set 10,000 years earlier Dune timeline, examining a political situation surrounding the early stages of the Bene Gesserit.
Desmond Hart is Duncan Idaho’s replacement
Desmond Hart Is Dune: Prophecy’s Tough Warrior Character
When Desmond Hart is first introduced in Dune: Prophecy premiere episode, he bears a striking resemblance to the Duncan Idaho archetype. He is a Veteran warrior who learned the ways of desert warfare to survive twelve voyages on Arrakismaking him one of the most valuable soldiers in the entire Empire. Hart is played by Travis Fimmel in Dune: Prophecy cast, an actor no stranger to epic television, having starred Vikings and HBO Raised by wolves.
Upon his introduction, Hart seems like the kind of arrogant soldier with an attitude that could suit Duncan Idaho’s presence. It almost seems like he could be the charismatic hero from the previous show. However, there is much more to Desmond Hart than initially meets the eye. It quickly becomes apparent that he is not quite right in the head, and there are layers of mystery to him that weren’t present in Duncan Idaho. Hart has an agenda regarding Selusa Secundus, and Dune: Prophecy The end of episode 1 shows him starting to execute it.
Desmond Hart becomes a great villain – and more powerful than Duncan Idaho
Desmond Hart has an agenda against the brotherhood
The first episode’s shocking climax sees Desmond Hart seemingly murder young Pruwet Richese, suggesting he will likely be the show’s antagonist. Although his exact reason is still unclear, Hart aims to destroy the Brotherhood, suggesting to Richese that they have gained too much power and control over politics. in the Known Universe. He also exchanged a suspicious look with the Emperor’s Truth Teller, Kasha, at the beginning of the episode. Emperor Corrino also sees Hart survive a sandworm attack, which is a miracle.
Hart’s mystical powers also present a sense of intrigue to his character, as there is nothing like what he does with Pruwet Richese in the books.
THE Dune The universe is typically more complicated than just having heroes and villains, with franchise leader Paul Atreides not falling into either category. With the Bene Gesserit being the protagonists Dune: ProphecyIt would make sense for Desmond Hart to be the antagonist, but it’s to be seen and discussed who is right or wrong. Valya Harkonnen is certainly not an unequivocal heroine. Hart’s mystical powers also present a sense of intrigue to his character, as there is nothing like what he does with Pruwet Richese in the books.
Desmond Hart Shows Why Dune Still Needs Jason Momoa
The Dune universe could use a little more humor
Desmond Hart has the makings of a fascinating character, but he’s also a reminder of how much the first film benefited from the performances of Duncan Idaho and Jason Momoa. Something Dune: Prophecy what is missing so far is humor and, again, although Dune It doesn’t have to be a comedy, having levity in such a sprawling and complicated fictional universe is a crucial way to make the world feel lived-in and meaningful. For these worlds to work and capture the public’s interest, Humor is an excellent way to give characters personalities beyond plot goals.
Although he has not yet been cast, Jason Momoa is expected to return for a planned 2026 Dune: Part 3. Yes, his character died in the first film, but the book Messiah Dune features something called a ghola, which is an artificial human being created using the remains of a dead person, and this is made for Duncan Idaho. This version of Duncan probably won’t involve as much humor; It’s possible that Denis Villeneuve’s adaptation will include more jokes to bring back the version of the character that audiences and, more importantly, Paul Atreides are familiar with. About that, Dune: Prophecy Could use a little levity.