This article contains a discussion of sexual violence and assault.
New Netflix documentary directed by Alejandro Hartman. Menendez brothersMechas appeared just a few weeks after the series’ release. Monsters: The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez, go to your streaming service. Both offer very different versions of the shocking 1993 murder. Jose and Mary Menendez in Beverly Hills, which their two sons, Lyle and Erik Menendez, eventually admitted to.
It was initially believed that the brothers took the 12-gauge shotgun to their parents simply to collect a $15 million inheritance, but a more complex picture emerged at trial three and a half years later. Lyle and Eric claimed that they were subjected to mental, physical and sexual abuse. by their father since he was six, and that they fired 15 shells at him and their mother only after Lyle threatened Jose with revealing their secret, and subsequently felt their own lives were in danger. According to them, this is why Lyle and Eric killed their parents.
The Menendez Brothers’ Netflix Documentary Is Perfect for Post-Monster Watching
The documentary shows Lyle and Eric in a completely different light
Menendez brothers is a timely reminder that there are two sides to this tragic story. The show’s premise is that Kyle and Eric were cold-blooded, heartless, and financially motivated killers, while the documentary suggests a more subtle implication that they were forced to kill by years of abuse and family dysfunction. Ultimately, Monsters: The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez upholds the first-degree murder charge that landed Erik and Lyle Menendez behind bars for life without parole, and Menendez brothers suggests that the lesser charge of manslaughter should have been brought.
“Both brothers testified about sexual abuse by their father.”
The documentary features first-hand interviews with both brothers, as well as their Los Angeles prosecutor, Leslie Abramson, who still insists:this whole defense was fabricated“; footage from the original trial, in which both brothers testified about their father’s sexual abuse, appears to contradict her, with Kyle and Eric’s emotional performances feel genuine and real. – whereas in the series they are portrayed as much more calculating and manipulative, especially in the scenes where after the murder they spend the money buying a Porsche and a Rolex.
How the Menendez brothers are different from the Netflix monsters
The series and the documentary have completely different points of view
The differences between a documentary and a TV series are stark: Monsters: The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez, Jose is seen as a controlling and abusive person, but the sexual abuse is purely emotional. Menendez brothers it’s both revealing and shocking. Likewise, the series does not take into account the testimony of their cousin Diane. who says Lyle told her about the abuse when she was an eight-year-old girl, and that she approached Kitty with it, but was released. The series features highly suggestive homoerotic and incestuous scenes involving two boys. Menendez brothers simply shows Eric admitting on the stand that Lyle once molested him.
The two productions treat O. J. Simpson’s influence on verdicts differently. During a mistrial in 1993, in which the jury failed to reach a verdict, the boys’ version of events was judged to have been effective; however, their second trial, which began a week after O.J.’s acquittal, saw Judge Stanley Weisberg refuses to hear much of the defense’s apparent abuse testimony.resulting in a quick and unanimous guilty verdict. The series explored it as part of then-District Attorney Gil Garcetti’s re-election bid, while the documentary focused on a vindictive judge supported by a wounded justice system.
What the Menendez brothers said about Netflix’s Monsters
Both brothers harshly condemned the monsters
Menendez brothers implicitly supports Eric and Lyle’s version of events, but rejects the possibility of including last year’s allegations by Ray Rosello of the boy band Menudo, who said Jose drugged and raped him when he was head of RCA. This discovery prompted the current Los Angeles District Attorney to reopen the case and review new evidence, something both Lyle and Eric had called for. Eric, in particular, reacted sharply to Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story for questioning allegations of sexual assault.
Meanwhile, Lyle insists that in prison he has become a sexual assault consultant for other prisoners, again lending his support to the stated defense of him and his brother. A third trial seems inevitable, and both The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez and the Menendez Brothers will contribute to this. Public opinion on this issue appears to have changed recently. with a loud and persistent “Free Menendi” campaign on the social network TikTok.who was convinced that the documentary’s view of the murders was correct.
Lyle and Erik Menendez, imprisoned for the murder of their parents, recount the crime and dramatic trial in this documentary.