The Lion King Proves Scar's Motivations Misunderstood With Dangerous Comparability

Warning: SPOILERS forward for Mufasa: The Lion King!

Mufasa: The Lion King establishes a reasonably easy origin story for Scar's hatred of his titular brother, however one specific facet of the narrative could also be deceptive for some viewers. Though The Lion King seems to ascertain Scar as a bitter loner who feels he's probably the most worthy inheritor to rule the Milele Pleasure Lands, Mufasa goes a lot deeper to ascertain the true roots of Scar's motivations.

MufasaThe main points of the story set up that Scar was raised with the expectation of turning into king, when he was a cub named Taka; nonetheless, the movie hints on the origin of Taka's hatred truly begins along with his obvious betrayal by the hands of Mufasa.. Rafiki even foreshadows this when explaining the motivations of Mufasa: The Lion King's Outsiders to Simba's daughter Kiara, telling her that hate comes from denying love. Whereas he's not completely mistaken, taking Rafiki's phrases at face worth solely serves to downplay the true complexity of Taka's character.

Scar's origin story in Mufasa falsely equates Taka with Kiros

Mufasa's Outsiders Have A lot Extra Proper to Really feel Unloved

Rafiki explains that the Outsiders, together with MufasaKiros' major villain, hates different lions as a result of they had been kicked out of their prides for having white fur and they're unable to forgive those that betrayed them, thus studying to hate their very own sort. This appears to ascertain a parallel between Kiros and Taka, the one downside is that Mufasa by no means abandons Taka's belief. Sarabi comes shut when she declares Mufasa the true king, including insult to damage by stating that Taka's solely actual future was to maintain Mufasa alive. All through this dialog, nonetheless, Mufasa constantly defends Taka's royal birthright.

It's then closely advised that Scar's true villainous transformation is triggered by jealousy of Mufasa and Sarabi's romance, however this nonetheless doesn't match the familial love denied to the Outsiders. Mufasa didn't fall in love with Sarabi on objective and tries to suppress these emotions out of loyalty to Taka on a number of events. The one motive Taka feels unloved or betrayed by Mufasa is just that Taka was not raised to know the distinction between loyalty and obedience. This doesn't equate Taka to Kiros, but it surely sadly provides one other layer of tragedy to Scar's origins.

Rafiki's interpretation of Scar's origin story isn't completely mistaken

Denial of his father's love was what actually scarred Taka

If any character truly deprives Taka of affection in any respect Mufasa: The Lion Kingis Taka's father, Obasi. It's clear that the 2 purest sources of affection in Taka's life are his mom, Eshe, and his adopted brother, Mufasahowever Obasi banishes Mufasa to stay with the lionesses and retains Taka segregated from the male lions each time doable.

Obasi then sows mistrust, claiming that Mufasa will someday betray Taka. Taka later recollects this prediction in his villain music, “Brother Betrayed,” wherein Taka painfully portrays his earlier emotions from "I All the time Wished A Brother" concluding that Scar and Mufasa aren't actual brothers in any case.

Obasi by no means permits Taka to like himself correctly. Taka reveals a number of indicators of innate kindness, however Obasi teaches Taka to suppress his ethical compass in favor of lazy self-interest. After Taka abandons Eshe and Mufasa to combat the Outsiders himselfObasi convinces Taka to lie so the tribe received't doubt that pre-Scar Taka will likely be a great king, however Obasi's actions additionally suggest what Taka secretly fears: Mufasa could be a greater king. This performs an necessary position in Taka's determination at hand Mufasa over to Kiros when Taka recollects Obasi's educating that nice kings know the worth of deception. Even earlier than Taka felt hatred, Obasi taught him how greatest to show it right into a weapon, rejecting any duty for his actions.

Mufasa: The Lion King Advantages From Scar's Complicated Origin Story

Mufasa doesn't truly have to betray Taka for the scar to make sense

A literal interpretation of Rafiki's lesson to Kiara may need drawn a powerful parallel between the movie's major villain and traditional Disney villain Scar, however it will even have ruined Mufasa as a protagonist. The aim of the movie is to indicate how Mufasa turned the clever and noble chief portrayed in The Lion King. Nothing would undermine that the Aristocracy greater than seeing Mufasa betray his adoptive brother, particularly when Scar saves Mufasa's life no less than 4 occasions all through the movie.

Seeing Taka's preliminary ethical similarities to Mufasa as a pet provides one other attention-grabbing layer to the narrative. If Obasi had not segregated his personal delight and denied Taka full entry to Eshe's love, it's debatable that Taka may have develop into rather more like Mufasa than he's. Taka even tries to redeem himself ultimately by leaping between Mufasa and what may have been a lethal blow from Kiros, explaining how Scar acquired his scar within the first place. Sadly, it's already too late to avoid wasting Taka and Mufasa's relationship.

Mufasa: The Lion King by no means sees Taka banished like Kiros, however his destiny continues to be tragic. Mufasa permits Scar to remain after his betrayal, however refuses to name him by his title once more. This brings Rafiki's lesson again to Scar's motivations in The Lion King. Scar has nothing left however to bitterly rule over a pack of hyenas whereas lamenting the times when he thought he could be king, having misplaced his title and royal birthright to the identical brother. And for Scar, because of his toxic upbringing by Obasi, shedding any of them is shedding all the pieces.