The intriguing plot holes of the first book and movie in the Harry Potter series implies that the mysterious Albus Dumbledore may not be as nice as he seems. Dumbledore is masterfully portrayed by Richard Harris and Michael Gambon, and they communicate the complexity of Dumbledore's psychology, which helps make the intrigue behind the plot holes incredibly real. Based on JK Rowling's book series, the Harry Potter Kino created an Albus Dumbledore who was simultaneously enigmatic, clever and threatening. In both books and movies, this great character often moved me to awe and anger.
I always knew that Albus Dumbledore was planning something in Harry PotterBut it was only as the series went on that I began to see why. As everything became clearer, I began to suspect that what I perceived as plot holes in earlier books might not have been plot holes at all and might be complex storytelling on Rowling's part. This is difficult to determine, with Rowling never speaking on the issue. However, there are many clues in the US Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone Movie and book to suggest answers. Dumbledore is complex and maddening, no matter what the case may be.
Related
The ending of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone is full of plot holes
The first movie doesn't make a whole lot of sense
I see a lot of plot holes in it Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, The sorcerer's stone was especially guarded about this road. Gryffindor's golden trio - Harry Potter, Ron Weasley, and Hermione Granger - are presented with a locked door on their way to retrieve the Sorcerer's Stone. They have to find a way to retrieve the key. First, I see no real reason for the key to be available so close to the door. The key could be placed somewhere far from the door, for safety. Second, there did not have to be a broom available to facilitate the retrieval of the key.
Related
The whole task was surprisingly easy for the first-year Hogwarts students, one of whom was very good at Quidditch, and therefore good at it. With a broom. I was also surprised that a job that required Ron's chess skills presented itself to the Golden Trio. Not to mention, there is no need to exit the area with the Potions challenge. It was easy enough for the Golden Trio, and Quirrell, to slip past this obstacle. I always thought that these Hogwarts staff could have thought of many other ways to keep older, gifted witches and wizards away from the stoneProtecting it more securely.
The Stone's protections only make sense if Dumbledore wanted Quirrell to reach it
There was a certain logic to the protection of the stone
It is true that Dumbledore and the Hogwarts staff may have genuinely set up the protection of the Sorcerer's Stone for no other motive, but the whole story makes much more sense to me if Dumbledore intended for these tasks to be manageable. The plot holes with the protection of the Sorcerer's Stone disappear if you accept that Dumbledore set the tasks to allow the Golden Trio and Quirrell to access the stone, which lead Harry and Quirrell to meet. I think that JK Rowling deliberately left this as a possibility for mature readers to ponder. I am impressed with this story and angry with Dumbledore.
It seems very much like the pursuit of the stone was a series of tests set up by Dumbledore.
The protection of the stone may have presented challenging tasks for many trying to reach it. However, for the most part, it looks like the tasks are made easy enough to be completed by students while testing their abilities. Significantly, I think the Hogwarts headmaster wanted Quirrell to reach the Mirror of Erised because he knew he wouldn't be able to get the stone out of it. The Sorcerer's Stone was safe in the mirrorIn fact, and Harry never needed to go after it. It seems very much like the pursuit of the stone was a series of tests set up by Dumbledore.
Harry Potter's plot holes may actually be part of Dumbledore's larger plan
Dumbledore guided Harry to his future
For Dumbledore to have planned the tasks of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone For Harry, Ron, Hermione, and Quirrell would be in keeping with what we know about him. After finishing the books, I realized how much Dumbledore had planned all along. The movies suggest this fit, despite not sticking to the texts word for word. Dumbledore meant for Harry to face Voldemort. In a twist that made me sad and angry as a child, it turns out that Dumbledore knew that Harry might have to die to save the world from Voldemort. Therefore, it makes sense if Dumbledore cruelly manipulated the events of book one.
Looking back at the plot holes in book one makes me more convinced than ever that Dumbledore's larger plan involved the events of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone. Dumbledore wanted to get the key fighters of the war that he saw coming readyAnd he wanted to know if they were right for his plan. Dumbledore was ruthless, as military leaders had to be - he was fighting a war. Therefore, his manipulation of the series' many intriguing and perilous goings-on is believable but sits in a gray area between acceptable and challenging. This is, of course, the wonder of his character.
Looking back on the series just makes me angry at Dumbledore
Dumbledore puts his students in danger
I still find Dumbledore's bold decisions infuriatingAnd find him even more maddening when I accept that he manipulated the Golden Trio into Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone. This is a testament to the flavor and multi-layered storytelling of the series. I also find Dumbledore to be a compelling leader. The plot begins Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone Crystallize exactly what it is about Dumbledore that makes him a dangerous man and a great character. I always found Dumbledore delightfully enigmatic.
And even when his intentions were explained to me, I felt that some parts of the old wizard were not explained enough. Upon closer analysis of the story's plot holes, I understood that they worked as simplified elements of a YA fantasy story, but also as a deeper examination of Dumbledore's serious responsibility. in this way, Rowling's books worked for both children, young adults and older readers. Dumbledore is a flawed, complex genius, making Harry Potter A thoroughly modern take on fantasy literature.