This alteration in Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith saved Obi-Wan Kenobi's character from being a lot darker. Revenge of the Sith isn't just one among Star Wars finest movies, but in addition probably the most necessary factors of Star Wars timeline. Among the many most engaging elements Revenge of the Sith is the connection between Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker, particularly within the interval main as much as Anakin's downfall. Anakin and Obi-Wan have been actually brothers and shaped one of many Star Wars finest pairs, which made the result of the friendship far more painful.
Nonetheless, a second excluded from Revenge of the Sith reveals how far more brutal this plot might have been. The 2005 ebook The Making of Star Wars, Episode III - Revenge of the Sithwritten by JW Rinzler, reveals that, initially, as Anakin was injured on Mustafar, he was going to say: "Assist me, Grasp," and Obi-Wan would deny him. This was in the end faraway from the ultimate lower of Revenge of the Sithbut when it had been left in, it will have fully modified the dynamic between these two characters throughout their encounter on Mustafar.
Purchase The Making of Star Wars, Episode III - Revenge of the Sith on Amazon
What Anakin's cry for assist would imply for Mustafar's duel
This could have fully modified how likable every character was
I had Revenge of the Sith I left this cry for assist, this might have made Anakin far more likable and Obi-Wan Kenobi a lot much less. Within the ultimate model of the movie, by the point Anakin/Darth Vader is half-dead on Mustafar, he feels nearly irredeemable (despite the fact that he is aware of how his story ends). He slaughtered puppies, slaughtered the Neimoidians, and Pressure-strangled his pregnant spouse. In his battle with Obi-Wan, he additionally appeared callous and only a shadow of the person and Jedi that Anakin as soon as was.
Anakin/Vader begging for Obi-Wan's assist would have modified issues. This could have made Anakin appear far more just like the scared boy he as soon as was on Tatooine and bolstered that Anakin felt misplaced and deserted. This could additionally go effectively with the clear unhappiness he displayed, particularly the tears he shed over Order 66. Alternatively, Obi-Wan would have gone from a heartbroken man who did the whole lot he might to somebody seemingly a lot colder. who might watch Anakin burn and never give him the assistance he was begging for.
The Making of Star Wars, Episode III - Revenge of the Sith additionally reveals that It will have been after Obi-Wan's refusal that Anakin's eyes would have modified from blue to yellowSith eye coloration. This could have added an interesting and devastating layer to the second, suggesting that it was in the end Obi-Wan's rejection that fully remodeled Anakin. Positive, he had already dedicated egregious acts at that time, however it will nonetheless be uncharacteristically brutal for Obi-Wan to see and listen to his former Padawan in a lot ache and easily watch, decide up his lightsaber, and stroll away.
Our tackle what this variation meant for Star Wars
I'm so relieved this variation has been made
I'm personally very grateful Revenge of the Sith I didn't preserve that dialogue. I'm already devastated by Anakin's downfall and his betrayal of everybody he is aware of and loves each time I watch the movie, and witnessing him ask for Obi-Wan's assist and be denied would merely be an excessive amount of. Sure, I'm conscious that the issues Anakin has carried out all through Revenge of the Sith (and even earlier than that) are completely horrific, however seeing Obi-Wan witness Anakin's struggling and actively reject his plea for assist would have made it a lot worse.
It additionally would have precipitated injury to Obi-Wan's character that merely wasn't needed. Obi-Wan definitely wasn't with out flaws, however seeing Anakin struggling a lot and listening to him beg for assist solely to be denied would contradict the compassion and kindness Obi-Wan demonstrated again and again in Star Wars-not to say the clear unhappiness he felt for Anakin and the truth that he nonetheless had a crush on him, even in Obi Wan Kenobi. That Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith second actually would have modified Obi-Wan Kenobi, and I'm so glad it was lower.
Supply: The Making of Star Wars, Episode III - Revenge of the Sith