Should you choose the fruit bat or the mushroom cave?

The choice between fruit bats and mushrooms is compelling for Valley of the Starswith both options offering clear benefits. However, Farm Cave can only support one of the two, and the upgrade is irreversible, just like Valley of the StarsChoose between the Rancher and Farmhand professions. This will have a lasting impact on a farm and the products people can easily obtain from it, and as such the decision deserves careful consideration beforehand.

It doesn't matter the layout of a Valley of the Stars Fifth, the Cave is found along its northern end. Although initially empty, local scientist Demetrius will approach the player with an offer after he has earned a total of 25,000 gold; To advance his research, he will equip the cave to support mushrooms or fruit bats. Either option grants access to produce, specifically fruits and mushrooms, with the exact types that appear being randomized. Both come with their advantages and disadvantages, although it is important to note that Neither option prevents the product of the other from being obtained by alternative means.

Stardew Valley's cave is incredibly convenient for collecting useful fruits

The Benefits of Choosing Fruit Bats

If Fruit Bats are chosen to fill the Farm Cave, then Mammals will start randomly leaving fruits and berries in the Cave at night. They may even be out of season, which makes Fruit Bats an excellent option for those who want to make a lot of Handmade Products. They also contribute to the Craft Pack found in the Community Center Pantry, which rewards people with a Barrel and brings the Greenhouse one step closer to restoration.

Many farmers have noted that the cost of fruit trees can be quite expensive and they often do not yield much during the season once they are planted. With Fruit Bats randomly giving out items that might not even be in season, the just the monetary value of getting these gifts from the Farm Cave might make this a good option for farmers to choose from. Crafting craft products will provide even more gold at a fairly fast pace, with little work required from the farmer other than collecting the fruits and berries and putting them into machines to make wine or other products.

Having easy access to these fruits and crafting your own can also make for perfect gifts for other Stardew Valley residents. This helps players quickly strengthen these in-game relationships, especially if they want a little romance. For example, Leah and Harvey love receiving wine, and several others love receiving specific fruits, such as Pomegranates for Elliot. If a farmer is thinking about romance with a specific neighbor, he should take a look at what that NPC's favorite gifts are.

Stardew Valley cave can be used to make life elixirs for miners

The benefits of choosing the mushroom cave

On the other hand, picking mushrooms causes common mushrooms, red mushrooms, purple mushrooms, morels and chanterelles to start growing in the Cave. Similar to the fruits of fruit bats, the exact mushrooms produced are random, but new mushrooms appear consistently every other night. Notably, the last four mushroom varieties can be used to create Elixirs of Life, making this option very appealing to the more adventurous farmers who want to dive deep into the Minas. Life Elixirs do not require any special crafting stations to make, but use Red Mushroom, Purple Mushroom, Morel, and Chantrelle.

Additionally, the Mushrooms found in the Cave also contribute to various Packs, and even come with a free Dehydrator that can turn them into Dried Mushrooms. Unfortunately, players must be careful when handing out gifts. Generally, Mushrooms are among the gifts hated by most residents. Additionally, eating too many of them can be deadly for the farmer, so they are not good emergency rations to have on hand.

Choosing the fruit bat cave is the best option in Stardew Valley

For most players. Still take individual playstyle into consideration

Overall, it seems that Fruit bats are the best option for the cave in many ways. While fruit generation is more luck-based than mushrooms, this is easily offset by the fact that the former has many more uses in the game. They can help complete Packs and make friends with the townspeoplebut they are also a valuable commodity in their own right. The cave allows the generation of 10 different types of fruits, double the variety of mushrooms.

The quality and frequency of Cave products must also be taken into consideration when deciding how to use them. For example, although the mushrooms are always of normal quality, the fruits harvested can be of any quality (iridium quality fruits are available from the botanist profession). On the other hand, in contrast to the Mushroom's consistent growth schedule, there is always a chance that no fruit will appear overnight (starting at 48% in a completely empty cave and increasing the more pieces are occupied), although any that do The make appear will remain there until collected.

Furthermore, the Fruit Bats represent an immense saving of time and money in obtaining Fruit from different Fruit Trees. While the travel cart may offer some savings, purchasing Pierre's six basic fruit trees will cost 25,400g, and they will each take 28 days to grow. Meanwhile, fruit bats can easily provide the six basic fruits of fruit trees for much less investment. Of course, Bananas and Mangoes are also found in Valley of the Starsbut none of them are available at Cave or Pierre. Instead, both fruit and saplings are only found after unlocking Ginger Island.

Regardless of the option chosen for the Cave, it will facilitate access to certain types of products. Of course, the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference, but from a mechanical standpoint, the benefits of Fruit Bats arguably outweigh those of Mushrooms compared to the average game player. Valley of the Stars. Perhaps the most valuable advantage of the fungal option is that Life Elixirs are potent items, but not everyone will need them to the point where the convenience of the Cave makes it worth choosing Mushrooms. Overall, the fruits left behind by fruit bats are much more valuable.