Obi-Wan Kenobi Iconic line in the original Star Wars Trilogy offers the perfect explanation for the shocking Palpatine twist in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. There are admittedly a number of issues with these Star Wars Sequel trilogy, though arguably the biggest was the minimally-explained return of Emperor Palpatine and his connection to Rey. In fact, although the sequels have some continuity issues, The rise of Skywalker’s Sudden left turn with Palpatine was one of the most glaring of all Star Wars Movies and TV shows.
The Star Wars Timeline has since worked to explain the return, mainly in Star Wars: The bad batchWhich revealed Project Necromancer and Palpatine’s resurrection plans. However, even with a little more context, The return of Palpatine remains confusing because it directly contradicts what has been established about Rey’s history. in Star Wars: The Last JediKylo Ren said that Rey’s parents were ‘nobody’ – a far cry from her father being a Palpatine clone. however, Star Wars Had the perfect explanation all along, given by none other than Obi-Wan Kenobi in Return of the Jedi.
Related
Obi-Wan’s half-truth about Darth Vader is prominent in Star Wars
The twist that Darth Vader is really Luke Skywalker’s father in The empire strikes back Was one of the most shocking turns not only in Star Wars But also in movie history. However, while the moment may now be iconic, at the time it posed some serious narrative issues. Namely, in A new hopeObi-Wan tells Luke that Darth Vader killed his fatherMaking this a massive recon. In fact, this happened because the twist was not George Lucas’ original plan; However, it requires an in-universe explanation.
The explanation came in the form of a rather cheeky line from Obi-Wan Kenobi’s Force ghost Return of the Jedi. Famously, Obi-Wan tells Luke, – What I told you is true… from a certain point of view. It is understood that Luke reacted to this statement with disbelief, clearly surprised (and probably a little confused) that Obi-Wan would describe his half-truth like that. However, this easy out of Obi-Wan is the perfect remedy to Kylo Ren’s similar lie in The Last Jedi.
This easy out of Obi-Wan is the perfect remedy to Kylo Ren’s similar lie in The Last Jedi.
Kylo Ren’s Last Jedi Half Truth is also true…from a certain point of view
The sequel trilogy turns an almost identical angle with its shocking Palpatine reveal. in The Last JediKylo Ren confirmed Rey’s fears that her parents were ‘nobodies’, adding that they were nothing more than that “Dirty Junk Traders” What she sold for drinking money. however, The Rise of Skywalker Completely rewrite that backstory, instead revealing that Rey’s father was a Palpatine clone, and they left her on Jakku to protect her.
The justification for this half-truth (if it can be called that) in The Last Jedi It was simply that Rey’s parents were technically nobody because “They chose to be.” Although this could almost explain the idea that Rey’s parents were not ‘important’ in the Star Wars The universe as the Skywalkers were, it did little to address the fact that Kylo Ren called them trash traders and said they sold Rey into slavery. Clearly, Kylo applied the same logic as Obi-Wan!
Of course, in fact, Obi-Wan’s cheeky response doesn’t really work in this case. Although somewhat opaque, Obi-Wan’s assertion was technically true. After all, Darth Vader repeatedly said he ‘killed’ Anakin Skywalker. The same cannot be said for Kylo Ren’s assertions in The Last JediWhich were more objectively wrong. Nevertheless, it means these Star Wars Sequel trilogy borrowed from Obi-Wan Kenobi Logic in Return of the Jedi When it came to Palpatine’s surprising resurrection in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker.