I nonetheless can't overcome the dumbest choice of the Jedi Council with Anakin

0
I nonetheless can't overcome the dumbest choice of the Jedi Council with Anakin

Node Star Wars Trilogy Prequel, the Jedi Council made a disconcerting choice on Anakin skywalker that I can't imagine it but. How anakin skywalker Star Wars The schedule turned extra developed, it was clear that its fall was not a direct matter, nor was Anakin's fault. He assumes duty for his actions - particularly the violent - definitely, however Anakin didn't fall to the darkish aspect within the vacuum.

As an alternative, there have been a number of defining moments on the darkish aspect of Anakin, a lot of them need to do with the dangerous choices of the folks round them. This began little question as quickly as Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace With Qui-Gon Jinn insisting that the Jedi Order accepts him regardless of his important issues. Properly after that, nonetheless, The Jedi Council made a singular and horrible choice that will nicely have sealed the destiny of Anakin Skywalker.

Sending Anakin to Naboo with Padmé was a fully horrible choice

Anakin's emotions by Padmé have been already obvious, in addition to his failures

Though Anakin and Padmé don't see one another The Ghost Menace and Star Wars: Episode II - Assault of Clonesinitially of Clone assaultAnakin was nonetheless in love along with her personal thought. Confused, given the Jedi Code, Anakin didn't forestall the Obi-Wan from how a lot he had desired over that decade and, as a substitute of punishing him or reminding him of the Jedi's place, Obi-Wan Riu Off .

That may have been dangerous sufficient, however The Jedi Council made issues a lot worse, attributing Anakin to be the Jedi who accompanied Padmé to Naboo When your life was in peril. This not solely gave Anakin significantly extra time with Padmé than he would have usually had, but in addition gave them a time alone in what was primarily a romantic escape. Though none of them might have seen this fashion, at the least at first, the spectacular situation of Naboo clearly ended up having this impact.

The Jedi ship a Padawan on this mission would have been unusual in the perfect circumstances, however Anakin's faulty nature and his emotions for Padmé made it a really disastrous situation. Anakin had already proven indicators of recklessness, ego and a disrespect for the foundations, which questions why he can be seen as the perfect jedi for work. It solely makes every little thing worse than Obi-Wan knew how Anakin felt about Padmé, and even he didn't intervene to inform the council that this was a horrible thought.

Anakin's faulty nature and his emotions for Padmé made this a really disastrous situation.

Might the Jedi have a hidden motive?

The jedi will need to have had motive for this alternative


Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker standing in front of the Jedi Council in the clones attack

Assuming that the Jedi will not be simply silly or incompetent (which is my perception, regardless of the quite a few errors of the Jedi Council), There could also be an inexpensive clarification for this weird choice. The Jedi might pay attention to Anakin's emotions by Padmé and his questionable loyalty to the Jedi Approach and have been destined for Naboo as a form of take a look at. If the case, they in all probability assumed that Anakin must select between being with Padmé and transferring away from the Jedi order or totally dedicated to the Jedi.

The Jedi might pay attention to Anakin's emotions by Padmé and his questionable loyalty to the Jedi Approach and have been destined for Naboo as a form of take a look at.

Theoretically, this isn't a horrible thought. If Anakin had been one other jedi, this puzzle very nicely might have him pressured to decide on one or the opposite. Nonetheless, Anakin was not simply Jedi, and he was not usually to disclaim himself the issues he needed- Even when this stuff have been mistaken.

The opposite query with this plan, if that's the reason the Jedi Council designated Anakin to this mission, is that they didn't affirm that Anakin selected. Sure, the clone wars began on the finish of Clone assaultSubmitting the Jedi and the Republic to Chaos, however that is fairly necessary to observe, particularly contemplating the standing of Anakin because the chosen one. Nonetheless, at the least when it comes to what was proven on the display, there was little investigation from the Jedi after Anakin's time in Naboo.

With out this mission, Anakin's emotions by Padmé would haven't gone anyplace

Sadly, the Jedi understood every little thing mistaken


Anakin Skywalker by Hayden Christensen falls to the dark side and is called Darth Vader, and he looks at Palpatine in agony

What makes this a really unlucky mistake is that With out this time in Naboo, Anakin's story would in all probability have appeared very completely different. Sure, Anakin already had emotions for Padmé in Clone assaultHowever he actually had no hope that these emotions have been nowhere. It was as a result of Anakin and Padmé shared this time in Naboo that Padmé developed their very own emotions.

Earlier than that, she had nonetheless seen Anakin as a boy, whom she even informed him initially of Clone assault. It was additionally simply because the 2 have been collectively when Obi-Wan was in peril that Padmé confessed to their emotions, as a result of she believed they have been about to die in geonosis. Subsequently, If the Jedi Council despatched Anakin to Naboo as a method of pushing him to a choice, this plan completely got here out by Culatra.

The unhappy reality is that with out Anakin going to Naboo with Padmé, he might not have fallen to the darkish aspect. This mission started his novel with Padmé, which turned the basis of his obsession with preserving him alive in Star Wars: Episode III - Sith Revenge. As this obsession was the inflection level for Anakin, it's not very exaggerated to say that this choice of the Jedi Council in Star Wars Sealed Prequel Trilogy Anakin skywalker vacation spot.