Qui-Gon Jinn's dying in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace is undoubtedly one of the vital pivotal moments within the Skywalker saga, however I nonetheless suppose it was an enormous mistake for Star Wars. Qui-Gon's dying is probably one of the vital analyzed moments in historical past. Star Wars prequel trilogy, as a consequence of this occasion's affect on Anakin Skywalker - significantly his eventual fall to the darkish aspect. The Duel of the Fates is so named as a result of it's a duel over Anakin's destiny - which Qui-Gon, sadly, loses.
As necessary as it's, I nonetheless suppose it was a mistake to lose a personality like Qui-Gon. In any case, he's performed by Liam Neeson, an iconic star who brings such a contemporary perspective to the character of Qui-Gon and that individual period of Star Wars. As Depend Dooku's former Padawan, Qui-Gon additionally has connections and relationships with necessary characters that no different character actually has. Whereas I wholeheartedly perceive the reasoning behind his dying, that is why I believe Star Wars ought to have let Qui-Gon reside.
Qui-Gon continues to be one of the vital attention-grabbing Jedi in Star Wars
After 26 years, he nonetheless has the most recent perspective on the Jedi
26 years after the launch of The phantom menace and thus the introduction of Qui-Gon himself, he's nonetheless one of many franchise's most attention-grabbing Jedi to this point. His perspective on the Pressure was, on the time, not like anythingand his calm willingness to interrupt the foundations of the Jedi Code to do what he thought was proper was very refreshing in a time when the Jedi had been much less tolerant than ever. Because the Jedi had been tasked with introducing midichlorians (also called M-count), Qui-Gon actually stood out from the remainder of the Jedi.
Sadly, no different Jedi launched on this period actually stood out like Qui-Gon, and it leaves me questioning what else we may have seen from Qui-Gon. I believe the truth that Qui-Gon was like that is what helped make Obi-Wan a extra versatile (and, though he would by no means admit it, extra relaxed) Jedi, just like the Obi-Wan we met within the final two earlier movies and in Star Wars: The Clone Wars may be very completely different from the Padawan who follows guidelines in The phantom menace. I'd like to see how Qui-Gon influenced him in that means.
The Jedi may have used Qui-Gon's voice in the course of the Clone Wars
He wasn't afraid to face the Council
It's no secret that the Jedi Order was very flawed even earlier than the beginning of the Clone Wars, however their heavy participation within the struggle additional led to their eventual downfall throughout Order 66. A lot of this needed to do with them specializing in the mistaken issues, issues that Qui-Gon would undoubtedly have expressed and defended with out restraint. The phantom menace proved that Qui-Gon was not solely keen to face the Jedi Council immediately, but additionally to problem them if crucialand the Jedi wanted extra folks like that in this era.
As a Jedi who longed to assist rid the galaxy of the issue of slavery, as seen in Claudia Grey's movie Grasp and Apprentice romance, Qui-Gon would have spoken loads in regards to the error of the Jedi's actions in the course of the struggle. Whereas one voice might not have been sufficient to dissuade the Jedi from all of the poor choices they made, Qui-Gon's will surely have carried extra weight than others. As Depend Dooku's former Padawan, it could even have been fascinating and attention-grabbing to see how Qui-Gon reckoned together with his former grasp's actions - though Qui-Gon's dying additionally performed a key function on this.
A lot potential died together with Qui-Gon himself
There was nonetheless a lot extra to discover with this character
Briefly, there was a lot potential in Qui-Gon's character that I'd have cherished to see past his tenure in The phantom menace. Fortunately, we bought some bits of his life earlier than that, within the aforementioned Grasp and Apprentice romance, the animated Tales of the Jedi collection and rather more, however I can't assist however really feel unhappy that he wasn't current for occasions as necessary because the Clone Wars.. It might nonetheless have been the case that Qui-Gon died earlier than Anakin's fall to the darkish aspect, however that occurred later, after the bonds had been shaped.
After all, it's additionally true that Qui-Gon's coaching of Anakin may have prevented his eventual downfall, but it surely's exhausting to say. Both means, I'd truthfully like to see the potential we really had with Qui-Gon in The phantom menace proceed. His character has all the time been a fan favourite, and I believe getting extra of his perspective inside the Jedi Order over time would have been actually fascinating. I perceive why The phantom menace I made that call, however I nonetheless suppose losing Qui-Gon's potential was an enormous mistake.