Hulu's A Court of Thorns and Roses Must Make a Tough Choice About the Fae

Sarah J. Maas' upcoming Hulu adaptation Cutting thorns and roses is highly anticipated. However, translating the series' rich lore, particularly the intricate and sometimes problematic aspects of Fae culture, to the small screen presents a unique set of challenges for Hulu. The depiction of the Fae courts in the book series introduces elements that may not resonate with modern audiences. According to Hulu updates on Cutting thorns and roses is not in active development, which gives the showrunners more time to consider these details.

Concepts how the fated companions trope, while prevalent in fantasy, can raise concerns about agency and consentespecially when viewed through a contemporary lens. Additionally, the presence of toxic masculinity within some Fae courts, with an emphasis on dominance and power, could potentially alienate viewers. Hulu faces a delicate balancing act – staying true to the source material while ensuring the series remains engaging and relevant to a wider audience. With Netflix leading its romance deal, Hulu is under pressure to get it right.

A Court of Thorns and Roses Fae Culture Presents a Tough Choice for Hulu TV Show

Fae culture may not sit well with a new audience

Sarah J Maas wasn't the first to portray Fae Courts in her romantic series Cutting thorns and rosesbut she did an impressive job building the lore and creating an engaging experience for readers. That said, the cultures of the Fae courts present a challenge for Hulu when adapting the feel of BookTok. Their customs may not please audiences less familiar with the ACOTAR world, in which toxic masculinity is present.

For example, The trope of fated companions is not restricted to Maas's work – it has been an important trope in Romanticism. However, until now, the book series has not significantly addressed its implications for the agency.for Fae women in particular. Hulu must solve this big Fae problem in Cutting thorns and roses. Elain has challenged her mating bond, but this clearly causes her and Lucien a lot of pain, and the other major couples in the series are fated mates. While this part of Fae culture will be familiar to ACOTAR readers, Hulu will want to reach a wider audience with the show.

The ACOTAR program risks being less faithful to the books with a progressive approach

An overly progressive approach can seem didactic and artificial

Cutting thorns and roses isn't set in a specific time, so arguably Sarah J Maas has every right to include a combination of high fantasy tropes and modern fantasy twists. However, this sometimes presents a social paradox, especially in translation for television. It can be disconcerting when there are eclectic, almost ren-faire historical aesthetics and fanciful responses to modern technology, like the magical ultrasound in A Court of Silver Flames.

However, The biggest risk of deviating from the books to ensure a progressive approach is undermining Feyre's characterization. Sarah J Maas' Cutting thorns and roses The heroine Feyre can certainly be criticized for not challenging certain customs, but making her too progressive and didactic would reduce her more cunning and strategic traits. For example, she wouldn't have been able to destroy the Spring Court from within without pretending to embrace her role in their culture.

Staying faithful to the source material may alienate potential new ACOTAR fans

Showrunners could combat this by spending more time challenging him

The ACOTAR show must find the right balance. Going too far in the progressive direction would reduce the fantasy element of the series – after all, Maas is inspired by Fae folklore, and the Fae are traditionally unpredictable and even capricious. However, the adaptation will need to make the Fae somewhat relatable to the viewer. Staying too faithful to the source material can alienate potential new fans. In addition to exploring Feyre and Rhysand's relationship at the start of the ACOTAR TV show, the producers are also expected to devote more time to the series' Fae culture.

A good way to do this would be to not change Feyre's character, but to put more emphasis on her as “curse breaker”. With her influence and her talent for negotiating with other courts, Feyre could enact major changes in the Fae realm. This must be emphasized in the program so that it does not come across as regressive. The show should also emphasize the more socially positive implications of the series. For example, A Court of Mist and Fury clearly shows that Tamlin's ruthless approach to Tithing is not how a leader should treat his citizens.