Harry PotterHogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry offers many classes for its students, from Transfiguration and Potions to Magical Creatures and Ancient Runes. While many of these classes are an educational requirement, there is one optional elective that should have been made mandatory for all students. Given Harry PotterThe Wizarding World of Hogwarts is just a secret society hidden in the middle of the real world - or the Muggle world - it is curious that Muggle Studies becomes one of Hogwarts' optional courses.
As students will still need to operate in the real world to some extent after they graduate from Hogwarts, it is surprising that the Muggle world remains a mystery to many wizards and witches. Not only does your knowledge of Muggle culture and technology seem to be lacking, but the series never explains whether the students continue their previous "Muggle" education during his classes at Hogwarts. Classes like math, English, and science would be valuable even at a wizarding school, but the series never confirms whether students continue to learn these skills after they transfer to Harry Potterfrom Hogwarts at age 11.
Optional Muggle Studies class at Hogwarts raises a question about the wizarding world without a clear answer
There are several skills that wizards would need in the Muggle world
The fact that Muggle Studies remains an optional course for Hogwarts students is baffling - especially when compared to the Harry Potter The books' persistence in keeping the Wizarding World a secret. Students would not only need to learn how to operate and integrate well with a completely different society, but also it is possible that they will require an extended education based on what they received before attending Hogwarts. We know since Harry Potter books that Harry attended a Muggle school before Hogwarts, and it is likely that other characters attended as well.
Given that elementary education barely scratches the surface of most subjects, it is contradictory that the Harry Potter the series never mentions them again. It is clear that basic mathematical, scientific and even writing skills would be applicable to the course load at Hogwarts, but the curriculum described in the books focuses exclusively on magical elements. This strange detail is neither denied nor confirmed as existing within Harry Potterof the tradition, and it is likely that JK Rowling never highlighted its significance in order to keep readers engrossed in the more fantastical elements of the stories rather than the real-world teachings.
The Harry Potter books don't deal very well with relationships between wizards and Muggles
The Muggle world is often treated as an afterthought
Relations between the wizarding and Muggle worlds are somewhat tense throughout the Harry Potter series, and This element may be a symptom of the wizarding school system's lack of focus on Muggle Studies.. The two worlds are considered completely separate, except in the aspect of local government, and only at the end of the books does Rowling explore this dynamic. It is clear from the short interaction between the Minister of Magic and the Muggle Prime Minister in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince that there is a significant lack of communication between the two societies.
While it is understood that the Wizarding World separates itself from Muggle society to remain secret, these scenarios could have benefited from some training if wizards had deemed it prudent to study and prepare.
In this case, the Muggle Prime Minister has just taken office, and only then does he discover the reality of magic and wizards. The conversation shows how little the Minister of Magic devotes to his own introduction and doesn't seem to pick up on social cues or understand the impossibility of the situation from a Muggle's point of view. While it is understood that the Wizarding World separates itself from Muggle society to remain secret, these scenarios could have benefited from some training if wizards had deemed it prudent to study and prepare.
The Harry Potter Remake Should Make Muggle Studies Mandatory (Or Address The Series' Plot Holes)
Hopefully HBO will build on this baffling Harry Potter scenario
HBO Harry Potter The TV series is currently in development and it would be nice to see the studio approach the issue of Muggle Studies differently than its source material or original films. The new adaptation has the opportunity to take advantage of some of the more baffling plot holes in the books and can hopefully faithfully address the issue without straying too far from the main narrative. THE Harry Potter books make it clear that the Muggle world is seen as an enigma for witches and wizards, but perhaps a look at the Muggle Studies classroom could help fill the gap.
Knowing that the Wizarding World has to operate within the Muggle world in some way from time to time, HBO's adaptation needs to recognize the series' small inconsistencies. Obviously, the world Harry Potter It's meant to be a fantastical escape from the real world, but that doesn't mean it needs to completely exclude a large part of its narrative. Additionally, several characters in the series were Muggle-born and their past experiences should play a larger role in the story. Harry Potter narrative of the series as a whole.