Greta Gerwig's frequent collaborator Saoirse Ronan should certainly be part of the Chronicles of Narnia reboot in some way, and a specific casting choice for her could simultaneously solve one of the biggest problems in the series' history. The beloved Barbie The director is delving even deeper into the fantasy genre with the Netflix film Chronicles of Narnia reboot and must write and direct at least two films in this new series. Jason Isaacs' recent tease about The wizard's nephew suggests that Gerwig may not be starting out with the Pevensie family, but will likely reach them sooner or later.
However, Gerwig Narnia The films face many challenges, including and especially elements vital to the story of the sister kings and queens of Narnia. Peter, Susan, Edmund and Lucy are expertly written as foils to one another as they embark on a magical journey to discover Narnia, becoming its ideal rulers, returning to their childhoods and bringing what they learned from Narnia back to their real lives. However, Susan has historically been considered to have the most troubled history of the Pevensie brothers – still, the much-demanded casting of Saoirse Ronan for Narnia It could improve this character arc a lot.
Casting Saoirse Ronan as an adult Susan could solve one of Narnia's biggest final problems
Ronan could do Susan justice if he portrayed her later in life, long after Narnia
At one time, Saoirse Ronan would have been perfect to play Susan Pevensie, but has now stepped out of the role, when Susan is in her late teens, the oldest. However, Ronan could simply play an adult Susan, even in a very brief scene. Susan could be a very effective framing device for the Narnia films through bookend scenes showing her in the real world, living a normal life, and reflecting on the past. Although satisfactory Bird Lady and Little Women fans, this could also be a way to resolve Susan's relationship issues Narnia history.
The fact that Susan never returned to Narnia after the events of Prince Caspian has been a point of contention among readers. However, exploring her life after Narnia could be the first step in creating a stronger story for her. Furthermore, it would be a brief role, but still important for Ronan, worthy of his talents. Ronan could take on a different smaller role in Narniabut it might be a waste of the Oscar-nominated actress. However, Susan is one of the main characters and someone fans want to see more of, so even the shorter scenes with her would be worth casting Ronan.
Greta Gerwig's Narnia Remake Should Resolve Susan Pevensie's Fate Issues
Susan always needed a better ending in Narnia
In the CS Lewis final Narnia romance, All of Susan's siblings return to Narnia without her. The reason for this is essentially summed up in Susan becoming a superficial and flirtatious young woman. The result is that she no longer believes that Narnia really happened, that it was just a game they played as children. Most importantly, the text characterizes Susan as a sexual adult, presented as a negative trait throughout the series when the characters are all children. Romances that take place between heroic adult characters are often kept out of sight, while wicked witches have notably sexual characterizations.
Of all the things Netflix's Narnia films should consider changing from the source material, this plot point is the one they have an undeniable obligation to change.
Of all the things Netflix Narnia the films should consider changing the source material, this plot point is one they have an undeniable obligation to change if the series continues long enough to show this. Scenes with an adult Susan showing her denying the existence of Narnia as a way to be happy with her life in the real world, while also emphasizing that condemning her for having any sexuality is unfair would improve her ending, while also rendered a metatextual moment that engages with both the history of the franchise and the outdated culture possibly still being portrayed.
Narnia's final questions must be carefully addressed in Greta Gerwig's remake
Netflix probably shouldn't make too many major changes to the Narnia story yet
However, deviating too much NarniaThe original ending may also upset fans of the books. The concept of one of the main characters never returning to Narnia contains some poetry, illustrating their different personalities. This is why Susan never returns to Narnia that needs to be handled better. The Pevensies live in a very complicated scenario where their different lives and different ages in Narnia and England collide, and it is plausible for character development that Susan's fond memories of Narnia were influenced by these jarring transitions.
Just a few scenes with Susan, ably played by an actress like Ronan, could fix her entire story. Her not returning to Narnia need not be a punishment; she could be a nuanced adult figure who has something to lose in the real world and whose ending constitutes a bittersweet message about growing up and moving on. With unparalleled creatives like Greta Gerwig and Saoirse Ronan, it's by no means impossible for The Chronicles of Narnia to finally bring justice to Susan.