George RR Martin’s original A Song of Ice and Fire plan would have avoided Game Of Thrones’ biggest final problem

0
George RR Martin’s original A Song of Ice and Fire plan would have avoided Game Of Thrones’ biggest final problem

There were some problems with Game of Thrones‘ ending, but one of the biggest could have been avoided with George R.R. Martin’s original plan to A Song of Ice and Fire. It’s no secret that Game of Thrones’ the ending was controversial, with its pacing and character regression being some of its biggest criticisms. The baffling choices made around the plot of White Walker and Daenerys’ Mad Queen turn all boiled down to the same thing: the writers rushing to the finish line too fast. However, there was another challenge that plagued the final ride.

Martin’s books being unfinished caused Game of Thrones to carve out his own path, using all the details Martin gave the creators about his ending. Unfortunately, this led to noticeable problems starting in Season 5. That’s another reason why the show’s ending was worse than previous seasons: it could only follow Martin’s outline, not the actual execution of it. This would not have happened if the author had kept part of his original plan.

GRRM’s original plan would have meant the books would be completed before Game Of Thrones

A Song of Ice and Fire was originally going to be a trilogy


Tyrion Lannister and Jon Snow from Game of Thrones
Custom image by Yailin Chacon

Original by Martin Game of Thrones the sketch was very different of the story that exists today, as it included developments such as Jaime Lannister becoming king, Sansa having a child with Joffrey, and a romance subplot between Jon, Arya, and Tyrion. The twist in Jon Snow’s parentage was one of the few things that remained in the original plan. And that’s even better – although there was another part that would have benefited the HBO show.

Since a trilogy would likely have seen Martin completing the books sooner, HBO Game of Thrones show would never have gotten ahead of them.

Martin initially intended to write A Song of Ice and Fire like a trilogywith Game of Thrones, A Dance with Dragons, and The winds of winter being the only books. That would have changed things much faster, while Martin’s seven-book series remains incomplete 28 years after the first book was published. And since a trilogy would likely have seen Martin completing the books first, HBO’s Game of Thrones show would never have gotten ahead of them. I would have source material to adapt from start to finish.

Considering that the show’s decline began when it ran out of material for adaptation, Martin’s original plan may have saved the adaptation from final season criticism. Of course, the story would be very different with just three books. It’s possible that Martin’s ending felt rushed, as its world and characters are a bit expansive for a trilogy. But the focus of what would have been his last book could also have solved another problem with the show’s conclusion.

George RR Martin’s original plan had more focus on the White Walkers at the end

Game Of Thrones concluded this storyline very easily

If A Song of Ice and Fire had been a trilogy as Martin intended, would have ended with The winds of winter – a book about Othersknown as the White Walkers on the show. This would have been an epic conclusion to Martin’s series, putting the spotlight on the biggest threat to Westeros. That was something Game of Thrones couldn’t, as the show concluded its White Walker storyline too quickly and easily. Instead, the focus returned to the Iron Throne, emphasizing the series’ entire argument about political intrigue over the threat to the North.

Although the current A Song of Ice and Fire plans will likely feature some conflict after the fight against the Others – the final book will be A spring dreamno The winds of winter – it’s doubtful it’ll be as big as Daenerys becoming the main villain. And even if development on this scale occurs, the Others will even have an entire novel dedicated to them. This will certainly be more satisfying than that episode Game of Thrones committed to his White Walker plot.

George RR Martin Now Has His Own Final Problem After Game Of Thrones

The show’s major plot points were poorly received


Jon Snow holds Daenerys' cheek in the throne room at the end of Game of Thrones

Unfortunately, martins A Song of Ice and Fire breaking up now has its own problem on the heels of Game of Thrones’ divisive conclusion. Leaving aside how long The winds of winter is taking, Martin must also deal with reactions to the show. It is likely that the main plot points of Game of Thrones’ the final episodes came from him. While they were likely executed differently in the books, the response to developments like Daenerys going mad and Bran becoming king were overwhelmingly negative.

Now there is added pressure on the author to deliver a satisfying ending to A Song of Ice and Fire, and this may mean rethinking certain developments.

This can’t be easy to face as a writer and may be contributing to the wait for Martin’s latest books. Now there is added pressure on the author to deliver a satisfying ending to A Song of Ice and Fire, and this may mean rethinking certain developments. It can also mean following what he has planned, but ensuring that it is carried out in a more satisfactory manner. However Martin handles this, one thing is certain: Game of Thrones further complicates his approach to the last two A Song of Ice and Fire books.

Leave A Reply