Do your choices in Stardew Valley really matter?

Stardew ValleyThe successful blend of a cozy farm simulator with combat and romance options leaves little to be desired, but the replayability of the game is sometimes a hard sell, especially considering choices made in the game often feel like they have no tangible impact. While more titles have started including multiple endings and secret cutscenes that force players to replay to see it all, It seems easy to get through everything the indie game has to offer without restarting.

But there are actually no consequences for the player Stardew Valley? Players can turn their children into pigeons in a creepy Stardew Valley Mechanic and even successfully date every marriage candidate without consequences if they have a Rabbit’s foot

On them all the time. Those who have worked their way through multiple playthroughs may feel like There is little that a farmer can actually do to wrong the townsfolk or suffer serious repercussions – But there are some choices that are harder to come back from than others.

Do the player’s choices really matter in Stardew Valley?

There are a handful of harmful choices

In a lot of cutscenes with villagers, there are several options a player can choose that actually affect their friendship level with that villager. Most of the options that would hurt a player’s friendship with a villager are pretty obvious to choose, Although most only deduct 10-50 friendship points. For certain marriage candidates, like Sebastian, there isn’t actually a wrong option players can choose during their cutscenes that would negatively affect their relationship – but that’s not the case for every villager.

Penny, for example, is the easiest marriage candidate to lose favor with. During her eight-heart event, when the school teacher begins to see a more serious future with the farmer, she asks the farmer to join her, Vincent and Jace on their field trip and be a guest speaker. Select the option, “No… I can’t stand children“, will automatically end the cutscene and deduct 1,500 friendship Points between the two, immediately drop them back down to two hearts with penny. This is the most extreme possibility and the only option in the game that will effectively destroy a relationship.

Other candidates, like Leah and Abigail, will take significant offense to certain answers (though none as extreme as Penny). Players lose 100 friendship points if they try to kiss Leah during her two-heart eventAnd Abigail will be similarly offended if the player tells her the mines are too dangerous for her. Lewis and Marnie will also lose 100 friendship points with the farmer if they threaten to expose their affair, though those are the only other serious offenses.

Either choice could permanently affect a relationship in Stardew Valley

How to quickly increase friendship with a villager

All that being said, it is actually incredibly easy to recover any lost hearts. Although the farmer’s friendship or relationship with a specific villager may take a dip, giving them a loved number four times will increase their friendship by one heart. Gifting a villagers Stardrop tea

(a new item added in the 1.6 update) will Automatically increase the villagers’ friendship by one heart, speeding up the process.

Other methods, such as constantly talking to the villagers, taking them to a movie, and completing an item delivery request will also contribute to increasing their hearts. Treating the villagers to a favorite movie (as long as the movie theater is open) will Reward the player with 200 friendship points – and another 50 can be added by buying them a snack they like. The Golden Pumpkin

, Primate Shard

, Pearl

, Play Magic Rock Candy

And Rabbit’s foot

are also all universally loved gifts, awarding the player 80 friendship points each time.

Fortunately, displacing a villagers in Stardew Valley Is not a mistake that will have lasting consequences. Even when a player has divorced a villager, it is possible to get back in their good graces With some gifts and quality time. There are several consequences for a player’s choices, though none are lasting or hinder the player from improving their friendship with a villager.