Denis Villeneuve criticized the Academy of Movement Image Arts and Sciences for disqualifying Hans Zimmer's movie Dune: Half Two rating thought-about within the Greatest Authentic Rating class on the 2025 Oscars. In line with Academy guidelines, a sequel's rating should include a minimum of 80% unique compositions to qualify. From Zimmer's work to Half Two incorporates substantial components of Dune: Half OneSadly, it didn't meet this standards. Zimmer already gained the Oscar for Greatest Authentic Rating in 2022 for Dune: Half One.
In line with Bar filmVilleneuve addressed the Academy's determination in a current Dune: Half Two screening. The sequence's music, though it drew closely from its predecessor, it featured unique preparations and themesand Villeneuve praised Zimmer in his feedback as a genius. Take a look at Villeneuve's full feedback on the disqualification under:
"I'm completely towards the Academy's determination to exclude Hans, frankly, as a result of I really feel his rating is among the better of the yr. I don't use the phrase genius usually, however Hans is one."
What this implies for the Dune franchise and awards season
The Academy has guidelines, however at what value?
The Academy's guidelines intention to make sure that the sequel's music is totally different from the earlier movie, prioritizing originality within the class. Whereas Dune: Half Two options a number of new items of music, its reliance on motifs, devices and leitmotifs from the primary movie aligns with Villeneuve's imaginative and prescient of the Dune sequence. This continuity, nevertheless, turned a vital consider scoring ineligibility.
Due to this, Villeneuve's disappointment with the choice displays the challenges sequels face throughout awards season. Though Zimmer's soundtrack enhances the general expertise of the movie, the Academy's determination comes from a place of awarding originality somewhat than thematic consistency. With the eleven-time nominated composer already holding an Oscar for the primary movie, the sequel's disqualification factors to the complexities of honoring franchises inside Academy pointers.
To date this awards season, Dune: Half Two confronted different awards-related obstacles. Obstructions embrace elements reminiscent of delay in launch because of the 2023 Writers Guild of America strike, which moved its premiere from November 2023 to March 2024. This delay doubtlessly impacted its visibility and awards marketing campaign momentumplacing much more stress on her recognition on the 2025 Oscars.
Our tackle Villeneuve's Oscar criticism
Hans Zimmer will miss the 2025 Oscars
Though the Academy's determination follows its requirements, Villeneuve's frustration is predicted due to how integral Zimmer's work is to the Dune franchise. Zimmer's music not solely enhances the visible narrative, but in addition connects the narratives of each. Dune: Half One and Dune: Half Two. The movie's disqualification raises broader questions on how awards guidelines accommodate sequels and serialized narratives, particularly at a time when franchises dominate Hollywood and past. Evilone other adaptation, thought-about his rating eligible for competitors within the class.
Supply: Bar film