Chainsaw Man Lost Its Original Film Director, But The Anime's Replacement Is the Best

0
Chainsaw Man Lost Its Original Film Director, But The Anime's Replacement Is the Best

Chainsaw Man - The Movie: Arco Reze has finally released its first trailer, and eagle-eyed fans will notice a big change in the team. Ryu Nakayama, the anime's original director, will not return for the film, which will be directed by Tatsuya Yoshihara, a notable change that can already be seen in the trailer presentation.

chainsaw manThe fact that the original director doesn't return for the film is disappointing, but it might not be as big a loss as people think. Ryu Nakayama's style was a big part of the anime's identity, so there is some discussion about the quality of the film after his departure, but thankfully, the Chainsaw Man - The Movie: Arco Reze trailer shows that the film is in great hands with Tatsuya Yoshihara thanks to his incredible visual style. Naturally, even this hasn't gone without criticism, but with the trailer looking so good, there shouldn't be anything to worry about.

Why Chainsaw Man's New Director Is a Great Fit for the Series

What makes Tatsuya Yoshihara a great director

A big part of why chainsaw manThe New Director Is So Good stems from the biggest criticisms that have been leveled at the anime. chainsaw man was highly criticized by fans and critics for its often slow and methodical pacing and animationas although the intention was to capitalize on the series' cinematic inspirations, it often didn't work because of how at odds it was with the energetic tone of the original story. The anime wasn't bad, but it's easy to see it as nothing close to what people were hoping to get out of it.

chainsaw manof the anime had its criticisms, and the film seems to be a great response to them. Not only are the characters and overall visual aesthetic reworked to be closer to the manga, but also the trailer for chainsaw man film shows the animation with the same energy that people associate with the manga, while maintaining the cinematic vibes of the animemaking a great compromise between the aesthetics of the anime and what fans of the manga expected. Tatsuya Yoshihara completely changed the overall aesthetic of chainsaw mananime, and it's hard not to see the benefit of it.

Tatsuya Yoshihara's skill as a director can be seen long before chainsaw manIt's the movie, of course. Not only was he the anime's action director, but Yoshihara has been involved in several action-heavy anime over the years, most notably as he was the chief director of Black Cloverit's the last season and is largely responsible for it looking as good as it did before. chainsaw manThe new director is someone well-versed in the kind of over-the-top action chainsaw man prosperand if there was someone who would replace Ryu Nakayama as director, there was no better way to go.

Chainsaw Man's new director brings the anime full circle

The meta reason why the Chainsaw Man director is so good


Denji, Aki and Power in the anime's first teaser

Another thing worth noting about chainsaw manThe new director is how he brings the anime full circle. Tatsuya Yoshihara worked on the original anime as an action director, but long before that, Yoshihara was the director of the anime's first teaser trailer, released when there was still no definitive release date for the series. With Ryu Nakayama's absence, the anime's new director needed to at least please the audience, so chainsaw man Getting the original director back for the film is the perfect way to continue the anime's legacy in Ryu Nakayama's absence..

Adding to this is the specific style of Tatsuya Yoshihara's teaser trailer. Much like the film's trailer, the first teaser trailer largely maintained the same energy and general style as the manga before the anime went in a radically different direction under Ryu Nakayama, and this ended up being a major part of the discourse surrounding it. As such, Tatsuya Ishihara becoming chainsaw manThe new director brings the series back to its roots on a meta leveland whether by accident or design, it's great to see for both old and new fans.

Why Chainsaw Man's original director won't return for the film

What happened to the original Chainsaw Man director?

There are many good things in Tatsuya Yoshihara's direction Chainsaw Man - The Movie: Arco Rezebut this, of course, raises the question of why Ryu Nakayama isn't returning. In August 2024, it was announced that Nakayama had been named CCO of Studio Mayflower, a relatively new studio, Ryu Nakayama's new roles at Studio Mayflower are probably keeping him from working chainsaw man. Being tied to one studio wouldn't preclude Nakayama from working at another, but unfortunately, that's unlikely to happen anytime soon.

On a less positive note, Ryu Nakayama's departure could be due to chainsaw man reception of the 1st season. Season 1 was highly controversial largely because of Nakayama's directing style, which caused Nakayama and MAPPA to receive a lot of criticism from fans around the world. Because of this, Ryu Nakayama may have left chainsaw man because he was forced to leave to prevent the film from receiving the same level of vitriol like the anime; This is all hypothetical, but since the film's aesthetic is different from that of the anime, it's unfortunately easy to come to that conclusion.

Does The Chainsaw Man movie's new style prove the anime's biggest critics were right?

Was the first season of Chainsaw Man as bad as people say?


Main visual from the movie Chainsaw Man

While Chainsaw Man - The Movie: Arco Reze It doesn't appear to be a complete departure from the anime's style, it's undeniably different thanks to the new color palette and brighter art and animation, especially in the few big action scenes featured in the trailer. It's true that anime films tend to have different styles than the shows they're based on, but with how radically big the change is, combined with Ryu Nakayama's unceremonious exit, It's easy to see the aesthetics of Chainsaw Man - The Movie: Arco Reze as proof that people were right to criticize the 1st season of the anime.

This idea is largely premature, of course. As notable as the criticism of the anime was, MAPPA higher-ups repeatedly spoke out about chainsaw man being a success, then Chainsaw Man - The Movie: Arco Rezethe style being so different from the anime is probably not a response to criticism and it's just a coincidence of Tatsuya Ishihara's specific style. In fact, the film's style can be seen as a natural evolution of the anime, and whatever the case, Tatsuya Yoshihara will certainly bring a lot of renewed energy to chainsaw man come 2025.

Source: Anime News Network.