Black Clover achieves something One Piece never could, and it proves why the first series deserves more praise

Yuki Tabata Black clover is often criticized for being one of the most unoriginal Shaun series, as it closely follows the familiar tropes of the genre. The story traces the protagonist’s journey to greatness, filled with the usual challenges, and the formation of friendships, bonds and rivalries that fuel the hero’s growth. However, there is one significant aspect of Black Clover that sets it apart: Asta, the main character of the series. Asta defies a crucial trait typically expected of Shaun protagonistsmaking the series unique in this regard.

If there is one series that comes close to that Black clover Reached, it’s Eiichiro Oda One piece. from the beginning, One piece Set itself apart by featuring Luffy as one of the most unconventional protagonists. Unlike many heroes whose destinies are predetermined, Luffy’s journey to becoming the King of the Pirates is Driven purely by his own free will. Luffy, despite not being blessed with amazing powers, worked hard with what he was given and made his power his own.

But, how One piece Increasingly, it began to present elements suggesting that Luffy may have been destined for his journey all along. In contrast, Black Clover consistently portrays Asta as someone who defies fate, never being the “chosen one”. In fact, Asta is the antithesis of a chosen hero, and thus, Black clover Accomplish what One piece Just hint of the beginning.

Unlike Luffy, Black cloverS Asta continues to embody his role as the unchosen hero

While Black clover Often criticized for its unoriginality, the series distinguishes itself by its unique protagonist

When a great series begins, it often establishes a foundation where the protagonist is either given a seemingly weak ability that they must work hard to master, or they possess a hidden power yet to be discovered. One piece Following the pattern with Luffy, whose initial ability was not particularly formidableBut quite intriguing.

As the series progressed, Luffy’s hard work led to the development of new abilities. However, the story eventually reveals that Luffy’s most powerful transformation was not a result of his hard work alone but was tied to destiny. This is highlighted by the revelation that the Devil Fruit Luffy ate was the one previously possessed by Joyboy, a legendary figure who passed his will through the ages.

in contrast, Black clover Brilliantly crafts Asta as the complete opposite of the “chosen”. He is the only person in the entire world born without a trace of magic in a society where people are measured by their magical abilities. This lack of magic sets Asta apart How truly unique, allowing the series to explore the concept of anti-magic, a power that ultimately helps him pursue his dream of becoming the Wizard King.

As the story progresses, Black Clover stays true to its initial premise, never forcing Asta into a role of destiny like Luffy, but instead builds on the idea of ​​an Ankosan hero who defies all odds. This is best depicted in episode #63 of Black cloverWith the title “Not in the least,” Where the Queen of Witches openly declares that Asta is merely a defective piece, not special in the slightest in a world brimming with magic.

One Piece’s Big Nika Reveal changed Luffy forever

It is true that the idea of ​​Luffy as the heir of the “Warrior of Liberation”, chosen by fate to carry out the will of Joyboy, may have looked out of place for long-time fans of One piece. However, it is also true that the series has always had another main theme, apart from freedom, and that is “inheritance will”. Gol D. Roger even mentions it in one of the series’ most iconic moments:

“These things cannot be stopped: Inheritance wills. People’s dreams. The ebb and flow of the ages. As long as people seek the answer to freedom, it will never cease to be!” – Goal the Roger

So, it is clear that the author Eiichiro Oda does not see the themes of freedom and an inherited will – or fate – as impossible to reconcile. At the same time, it’s also worth mentioning that Asta’s lack of magic allowed him to wield and master a power that could be considered far superior, antimagic, so there’s an element of predestination there as well.

At the end of the day, both series and characters are more nuanced that they look on the surface. For the brilliant and consistent execution of Asta’s unique image, Black clover deserves more praise than it gets, as it also delivered on the promise of an unconventional protagonist perhaps better than One piece.