Former Army Sergeant Lamont Christian analyzes scenes from Band of Brothers
giving the program a high accuracy rating in some important moments. Executive produced by Steven Spielberg and Tom Hanks following their acclaimed collaboration on Saving Private Ryanthe hit HBO series released in 2001, following the members of Easy Company from training to the liberation of Europe. Band of BrothersThe first episode focuses on his military and airborne training under the guidance of David Schwimmer’s Captain Sobel.
In a recent video for InsiderChristian takes a look Band of Brothers‘ training sequences, giving the program a high rating for its accuracy. The former sergeant uses the show’s skydiving scenes to share some of his key experiences as a skydiver, celebrating the depiction of that moment of hesitation before jumping from an aircraft as a new recruit. Check out Christian’s comment below:
While Sobel, in this series, may have been a great trainer, he didn’t necessarily have experience in tactical combat, because most of these men didn’t. In World War II, we had people who were teachers, bus drivers, and milk deliverers who were hired to serve our country and serve in infantry positions. I am of the opinion that it is not necessarily necessary for a trainer to have combat experience to be a great trainer.
I’d say it’s definitely realistic, especially being done at Camp Mackall. This series, Band of Brothers, takes a lot of the story from the real people who participated in this experience.
Basically, this is Army Airborne school and they’re taking the fifth leap. Five jumps are required to complete Airborne training. And so airborne training is advanced training that you go to after you complete basic training and then you learn your professional skills, whatever they may be.
So I actually like the fact that these paratroopers are also jumping because of my own connection – I served as a paratrooper in the 82nd Airborne Division. And what I will tell you is that my experience is unique because I went through jump school when my father was an airborne instructor, commonly called Black Hat. That’s pretty realistic, having served as a jump master, getting people out of the plane, you know. , you have someone who hesitates at that door like that.
I would say 10, but I’ll give it nine just because it wasn’t there.
What Band Of Brothers’ Accuracy Means For The Show’s Legacy
The HBO series is acclaimed and loved
Band of Brothers was widely celebrated at the time of its release and currently enjoys an impressive 94% critic score on Rotten tomatoes. The show was nominated for 20 Emmy Awards and won seven, including Outstanding Directing for a Miniseries. In addition to the narrative and the performance of the Band of Brothers cast, the show’s historical accuracy was also a major point of praise, with the real members of Easy Company appearing in interviews before each episode’s content.
|
Show title |
Rotten Tomatoes Critics Score |
Rotten Tomatoes audience score |
|
Band of Brothers |
94% |
96% |
|
The Pacific |
89% |
90% |
|
Masters of the Air |
85% |
72% |
Band of Brothers It was such a success that Spielberg and Hanks later collaborated further to bring additional World War II theater screens to life. The Pacific took the same approach with the US Marines fighting the Japanese in the Pacific, while Apple TV+ Masters of the Air chronicled the lives of key members of the 100th Bombardment Group as they carried out missions in Europe. Band of BrothersAs can be seen from the graph above, it remains the most celebrated of the three shows, and its respect for real history certainly remains one of the main reasons for that.
Our Take on Band Of Brothers’ Historical Accuracy
Its authentic portrayal of World War II helps elevate it
Like most films and shows depicting World War II, Band of Brothers It will certainly feature some embellishments and aspects that are added for dramatic effect or entertainment value. Overall, however, was clearly done with true respect for the men of Easy Company and their accomplishmentsand much attention was paid to presenting an authentic version of events.
Even if some aspects of the show are incorrect or stretch the truth, the intention behind the show helps make these moments forgivable. Additionally, some of the errors are likely so small or specific that the average viewer wouldn’t even notice. While historical accuracy is far from the show’s only strong point, it’s certainly part of the reason why Band of Brothers remains one of the best HBO miniseries of all time.
Source: Insider