‘A Year in the Life of Rory’ Suggests Sad Logan Plot if ‘Gilmore Girls’ Season 9 Ever Happens

Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life served as much needed Gilmore Girls reunion after its release in 2016, but one detail from the miniseries suggests that any potential sequel would include Logan’s sad story. The four-part reunion saw Luke Danes and Lorelai Gilmore get married, Richard Gilmore die and Rory’s shock pregnancy announcement. A key theme of the sequel, like the original series, is the exploration of generational patterns. However, the cyclical structure of history suggests that if Gilmore Girls In season 9, the heartbreaking story may repeat itself.

Rory was born when her parents were 16, and her mother, Lorelai Gilmore, insisted on raising her on her own. Lorelai was afraid that she would be pressured into marrying Rory’s father.Christopher is so young and moved to the small town of Stars Hollow to start a new life. As an adult, Rory suffered the same fate: in her 30s, she began an affair with her wealthy ex-boyfriend Logan Huntzberger and became pregnant. The show hints at her plans to raise this child on her own. Despite the parallels between Logan and Christopher, Logan is far more responsible, and removing him from raising a child would be a tragic repeat of history.

Logan is almost certainly the father of Rory’s baby on Gilmore Girls

Rory has an affair with Logan despite his engagement to someone else

While the end A year in the life leaves the name of Rory’s baby’s father deliberately ambiguous, it is clear that the father is most likely Logan. Rory and Logan continue to be intimate years after she turned down Logan’s proposal at Yale’s prom. Logan has since become engaged to a woman named Odette, who is never shown on camera.

It remains unclear why the couple never reunited, but viewers can speculate that the new engagement is potentially a result of the familial pressure Logan once experienced during the couple’s college years. Given that the revival doesn’t show any other significant relationships in Rory’s life, it is reported that Logan is the father, which is confirmed A year in the life costume designer Valerie Campbell (via Collider).

With Rory caught in a career rut and continuing to follow the same toxic habits she did when she was younger, it’s clear that she’ll try to raise the child on her own. Although the affair is unethical, Logan is a much more respectful and obedient person than Rory’s father, Christopher, despite their shared old money background, and would immediately like to help raise the child. For Gilmore Girls repeating the cycle will be frustratingas Rory was given so many tools to avoid the same struggles her mother went through.

Christopher’s “A Year in the Life” Scene Suggests Logan Won’t Be in Baby Rory’s Life

This key scene confirms the mirror theory of Rory’s fate

In a meta moment, Rory decides to write and title a book about the lives of her family, specifically the women. Gilmore Girls. When Rory questions her relationship with Christopher, asking him why he never fought to be a more active parent to her, it becomes clear that Rory is not only looking for answers, but also trying to assess how Logan will behave in this situation.. While Rory, at 30, has the advantage of a high-quality education and an independent life, Logan, being a generally responsible person, has now built his own life in London. This makes viewers wonder if Logan will follow the same path as Christopher.

Christopher expresses regret at leaving Lorelai as a co-parent so easily, but makes it clear that he believes Lorelai is better suited to be a parent. At the same time, he is trying to absolve himself of responsibility – in fact, he was only willing to become a parent if he was romantically involved with Lorelai. It is this aspect of the model that explains why Logan’s story should not repeat Christopher’s story.

‘Gilmore Girls’ Season 9 Shouldn’t Repeat Christopher’s Story With Logan and Rory’s Baby

Rory broke too many patterns to repeat this one.

In Christopher’s absence, Luke Danes acted as Rory’s father figure, even when his relationship with Lorelai was purely platonic. In his own way, Luke’s nephew, Jess Mariano, finds himself in a similar support role to Rory as an adult, as he matures and charts a secure life path in the publishing world. Jess encourages Rory to stay true to herself and return to Yale after she drops out, and encourages her to write her book on A A year in life.

As Jess looks wistfully at Rory through the window, it becomes clear that, despite his protests, Jess has never been able to forget Rory. His lingering feelings, coupled with his instinct to help her in her time of need, mirror his uncle’s relationship with Lorelai, making him an ideal candidate to serve as a surrogate father to Rory’s unborn child if Logan decides to be away.

The biggest difference between the two stories is that both Rory and Jess are more socioeconomically superior than Luke and Lorelai because both the uncle and the mother worked to provide better opportunities for their nephew and daughter respectively. While the mirror storyline between Lorelai and Rory’s pregnancies may illustrate that this struggle transcends generations, in a modern climate, it would not make sense for these systemic problems to cross class lines.

Will there ever be a Gilmore Girls season 9?

Series creator Amy Sherman Palladino is open to it

In 2023, series creator Amy Sherman Palladino confirmed that she was certainly open to continuing the show and exploring the next generation of characters. Palladino has previously expressed disgust at the ending of several characters’ stories, namely Lane Kim. She said that “families are forever dysfunctional, and so that’s the best way to come up with stories because you’ll never solve your problems there.” (by using Rolling Stone). She went on to clarify that there is still more to expand on, which she hopes to explore now in the streaming era with fewer time constraints.

Lauren Graham, who plays Lorelai Gilmore, told the publication that “no current plan“for another revival, but she will be ready to return if there is one. Sherman Palladino has confirmed that the ninth revival Gilmore Girls season is definitely on the table in the future. This means fans may yet get some resolution regarding the ongoing mystery of Rory’s parenting journey.

Sources: Collider, Rolling Stone