This article contains references to sexual assault.
Tyrion Lannister is one of the main characters in HBO Game of ThronesBut he is very different from the protagonist portrayed in the books. The TV fantasy epic is adapted from George RR Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire book series, a saga known for taking traditional fantasy genre norms and subverting them with a darker and more realistic setting. While early seasons of Game of Thrones Putting considerable effort into embracing this critical thematic approach, Tyrion began to change more and more after season 4 from his book counterpart.
Tyrion Lannister is a noble man in the world of Westeros, but being born a dwarf puts him at odds with his father, Tywin Lannister. Compared to his golden boy brother Jaime Lannister, Tyrion experiences prejudices and struggles that would not typically befall one of the richest men on the continent. in Game of ThronesTyrion handles this with self-awareness and acceptance, but the book version is often much more vindictive and cruel in response to how he was treated. Many have argued that the image of the book is more realistic and sophisticated, especially after reactions to game of thrones ending
10
Taeyeon’s physical appearance is different in A Song of Ice and Fire
Tyrion is made more attractive in the show and does not lose his nose
Before examining notable narrative differences, it is important to set the stage for these Difference in how George RR Martin establishes Tyrion in comparison to Game of Thrones. During the original run for the HBO series, Martin was once asked what he believed to be the best portrayal of one of his characters, to which he responded by describing Peter Dinklage in the role of Tyrion Lannister. Watch the video below:
He notes that although Peter Dinklage nails many of the basic Tyrion Lannister qualities, the American actor is a handsome man and looks nothing like the notably unattractive book counterpart. Tyrion, in the books, is described at times as monstrous. After the Battle of Blackwater Bay in A clash of kingsTyrion Lannister loses his noseWhile the TV version only takes a scar across his cheek. Dinklage’s performance is outstanding, but it’s clear that the HBO adaptation wanted a more physically presentable protagonist.
9
A plot twist about Tisha drastically changes Tyrion’s arc
Tysha really likes Tyrion in the books
Tisha was actually not a prostitute and was just a low-born woman who showed genuine affection for Tyrion
in Game of Thrones Season 1Tyrion Lannister shares an anecdote about how he once married a prostitute that Jaime paid To express romantic interest in him. After Tyrion’s heartbreak at this realization, Tywin forces him to watch as his soldiers rape her before eventually killing her. in A Song of Ice and FireTyrion’s arc is changed drastically when Jaime reveals that Tisha was not actually a prostitute and was just a low-born woman who showed genuine affection for Tyrion. This twist never happens in the show.
This turns Tyrion’s world upside down, but another major difference is ThaTisha still believes that he lives in the books. This changes the dynamic of the scene where Tyrion kills Tywin, as Tisha is the woman Tywin constantly calls a “whore”, causing Tyrion to shoot him with the crossbow. in A dance with dragonsTisha is often on Tyrion’s mind as he hopes he will meet her somewhere in his travels in Essos.
8
Tyrion is a much more vengeful and dark character in the books
Tyrion is a more challenging protagonist to follow
It is known that Tyrion’s personality is drastically different in the later seasons of the TV series than it is in A dance with dragons. Given the character’s immense popularity in Game of ThronesIt’s likely that HBO and the showrunners didn’t want to subject audiences to the much darker and more complex elements of the character.In fear of fans finding the material too harrowing. But Tyrion isn’t all dark A dance with dragonsHe had his moments even before killing Tywin.
Tyrion killed a man named Simon Silvertongue for learning his secrets and literally turned him into a stew.
The TV series paints him to be one of the most morally upright characters in King’s Landing, and while this is still likely true in the books due to the low bar for morality set in the Red Keep, he is not above blackmail, murder, and others. Incorrect. There are Some moments in the books that describe sex scenes with women who did not really agree. Not to mention, in A storm of swordsTyrion killed a man named Simon Silvertongue for learning about his secrets and literally turned him into a stew to be fed to the common people in Flea Bottom.
Related
7
Cersei fears Tyrion due to the “Valonkar” prophecy
One of Cersei’s biggest motivations is leaving the show
Game of Thrones Season 5 begins with one of the rare flashbacks of the TV series as it opens with a scene of Cersei Lannister as a child. She visits a forest witch named Maggie the Frog, who tells her that she will outlive all her children And that a younger, more beautiful queen will come to replace her. This ties back to the present-day story in King’s Landing, where Cersei believes that Margaery is the aforementioned younger queen, when the prophecy is actually referring to Daenerys.
The biggest difference between Maggie the Frog’s prophecy in the show and the book is that in A feast for crows, Cersei is also told that she will be killed by the “Valoncar.” It’s a High Valyrian word meaning “little brother,” which becomes a primary contributing factor to Cersei’s endless hatred of Tyrion, as she believes he will eventually kill her. Many have theorized that the prophecy actually refers to Jaime, who is her younger twin. Read the Maggy the Frog quote below:
“And when your tears have drowned you, the Valonker will wrap his hands around your pale white neck and choke the life out of you.”
6
Tyrion descends into his darkness in a dance with dragons
Book 5 takes Tyrion to his darkest point yet He imagines assaulting Cersei and mounting her and Jaime’s heads on spikes.
In the books, Tyrion is depressed and in agony after the news about Tisha and killing Tywin. While he previously carried a chip on his shoulder, his necomedic side is amplified after A storm of swordsturning him into a much darker character. His POV chapters in A dance with dragons are some of the hardest to read in the entire sagaAs his entire motivation becomes to destroy Cersei. In the show, his cause is more noble as he begins to support Daenerys out of nobility and honor for the realm.
He imagines assaulting Cersei and mounting her and Jaime’s heads on spikes. He dreams of killing Tywin and Jaime in battle, demonstrating a deep-rooted anger that seems to possess him in his arc ahead. The TV series shows Tyrion recovering from the world-changing event of killing his father rather quicklyAnd he constantly maintains some level of sympathy for Cersei. In the books, this is far from the truth.
5
Tyrion meets “Young Griff” in a dance with dragons
Tyrion meets a Targaryen before Daenerys
One of the main book differences surrounding Daenerys Targaryen in A Song of Ice and Fire is that she is not the only Targaryen after Viserys. At least, allegedly. in A dance with dragons, Readers are introduced to young Griff, a young man who is apparently the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Elia MartellGive him a better claim to the Iron Throne than Daenerys. Young Griff has been in hiding for years, but with the support of Illyrio Mopatis and Jon Connington, a plot is hatched to plant him as king.
Throughout the book, Tyrion sails with Jon Connington and Young Griff, also known as Aegon Targaryen, from Pentos to Volantis. Along the way, there are several notable events, including Tyrion realizing Young Griff is the long-lost Targaryen heir and Jon Connington rescuing Tyrion from the Stone Men, which causes the exiled lord to be infected with grayscale. In the TV series, the grayscale plot is given to Jorah Mormont.
4
Tyrion meets a dwarf woman named Penny in ASOIAF
Penny never made it into HBO’s Game of Thrones adaptation
Penny is a character in A Song of Ice and Fire Who is known in A dance with dragons Due to her connections with Tyrion. She never appears and is never mentioned in the TV series. Penny is a dwarf, and her brother, also a dwarf, is murdered in Volantis by men who believe him to be Tyrion LannisterBecause Cersei offered a reward for his death. Later she sees Tyrion and decides to attack him out of anger for her brother.
Despite trying to kill him, Penny befriends Tyrion. Penny does have a romantic crush on Tyrion, kissing him at one point, but he is burdened by his experiences with Tisha and Shay, causing him to disregard her rather cruelly. During this period when Tyrion is subject to self-pity and anguish, Penny is important as a reality check, holding him accountable to his moral compass. Tyrion constantly treats her poorlyBut her positive personality contrasts with his general self.
3
Shah begs Tyrion for mercy in a storm of swords
Xi’s murder is a brutal scene
Tyrion killing Shay before killing Tywin is a pretty dark scene game of thrones Season 4 finale, but it’s even darker in the books. In the show, Shay is portrayed as a selfish antagonist, using her situation with Tyrion to her own advantage, betraying him during the trial and then betraying him further by sleeping with his father. in A storm of swords, The moment still ends with Tyrion strangling her with a chain, but the dynamic shifts, and he certainly doesn’t apologize for it..
Related
In the book, she begs Tyrion for mercy, even calling him her “Giant of Lannister– asked him to strangle her to death in revenge, before she is killed, She claims that Cersei was forced to turn against him and that she is afraid of Tywin and doesn’t fight back when he hears her.. in A feast for crowsCersei’s POV chapters provide some more insight into Shay’s handling of the trial, showing that the Queen Regent has promised Shay a house in King’s Landing with a knight to marry.
2
Tyrion & Jaime’s relationship isn’t that solid in the books
Tyrion dreams of killing Jaime in A Dance with Dragons
Another aspect of Tyrion’s story that Game of Thrones Is away from his relationship with Jaime. Jaime Lannister is the only family member who ever shows Tyrion genuine love and respectBut their relationship is torn apart by Tyrion finding out about Tysha and then Tyrion killing Tywin. in Game of ThronesJaime vows to kill Tyrion for killing their father, but they end a loving relationship in season 8.
It’s hard to imagine that Tyrion and Jaime’s brotherly bond will return A Song of Ice and Fire. Tyrion’s hatred of Cersei is so extreme that he demands that he “May be allowed to rape and kill“You in return for helping Daenerys, and his thoughts on Jaime aren’t much better. He’s certainly not above causing harm to Jaime, either emotionally or physically, and imagine doing so on multiple occasions.
1
Tyrion’s supporting character relationships are different
Bronn is really just there to get paid
During Tyrion’s seasons in King’s Landing early on Game of ThronesHe starts to accumulate a supporting cast of followers. Bronn and Shae are shown to be his most loyal companions, and although their relationships are transactional, there are moments where they express genuine friendship. Bronn is much more open about the fact that he would sell Tyrion, but his performance in the series often suggests that he has some loyalty to him.
in the books, Bronn and Shay both seem to regard themselves as just Tyrion’s employees. Bran, in particular, has zero interest in being friends with Tyrion and would likely offer zero courtesy to the Lannister lord if he stopped getting paid. Again, this is a matter of softening Tyrion up Game of Thrones To make the image of Peter Dinklage more likable and easy to root. George RR Martin’s version is arguably more realistic for the environment of Westeros, and he is undoubtedly a more challenging character to follow.