Forget Hydra Captain America, I Found Out Exactly Which Marvel Character Chris Evans Should Play in Avengers: Judgment Day

While there are many rumors that Chris Evans will return to the MCU as a Hydra-aligned variant of Captain America, I'm convinced that Evans should play an entirely different character in Avengers: Judgment Daythe Beyonder. When Chris Evans hung up his shield as Captain America in Avengers: EndgameIt felt like the end of an era. Now he's returning to the MCU timeline in an undisclosed role, although there are several likely characters Chris Evans could play. However, the one that was not included in this debate, I think may be the most viable: the Beyonder.

Chris Evans' tenure as Captain America helped cement the MCU's status as a cultural juggernaut. Over the course of a decade, he transformed Steve Rogers into an aspirational and relatable character, embodying values ​​that resonated deeply with audiences. However, his departure in End of the game closed the door on that chapter in the MCU timeline, paving the way for Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson to inherit the mantle in Captain America: Brave New World.

Chris Evans is reportedly returning to the MCU for Avengers: Doomsday, but his role is not known

Chris Evans has been reported to return in the MCU Avengers: Judgment Day. Although details remain unclear, speculation runs rampant. The immediate assumption could be a multiverse variant of Captain America, like Hydra Cap or an alternate universe Steve Rogers. However, Such roles can undermine the emotional purpose of your End of the game bow.

Marvel Studios appears intent on leveraging nostalgia strategically, as seen in the casting of Robert Downey Jr. as the MCU's Doctor Doom. Instead of retreading familiar territory with a Captain America variant, Evans could follow suit and play an entirely different character. In fact, Evans' return could align with Marvel's ambitious exploration of cosmic and metaphysical themes. A character like the Beyonder would allowing Evans to leave his Steve Rogers persona intact, while also offering a radically new experience for audiences.

Avengers: Doomsday is believed to lead into Avengers: Secret Wars

Marvel's multiverse saga culminates in two colossal films: Avengers: Judgment Day and Avengers: Secret Wars. Billed as back-to-back episodes, these films will be released a year apart, reflecting the structure of Infinity War and End of the game. Judgment Day It is therefore expected to prepare the ground for Secret Warsa plot steeped in multiversal chaos and Epic battles on a patchwork planet known as Battleworld.

This setting, first introduced in the 1984 comic book “Secret Wars,” was reimagined in Jonathan Hickman's 2015 event, which merged alternate realities into a single domain ruled by Doctor Doom. The connective tissue between these films is it will likely be a cosmic entity with the power to orchestrate such a scenario. Enter the Beyonder, an omnipotent being who manipulates reality and brings together heroes and villains for his great experiments. Given Marvel's penchant for reinterpreting its source material, the Beyonder's involvement seems almost inevitable.

MCU Theory: Chris Evans Will Play Beyonder in Avengers: Doomsday

With Chris Evans returning to the MCU, reprising Steve Rogers seems unlikely. In the end, End of the game gave the character a moving and definitive farewell. Instead, Marvel could follow a similar strategy to Robert Downey Jr.'s return as Doctor Doom: Recasting familiar actors in unfamiliar but essential roles.

In the 1985 miniseries “Secret Wars II”, the Beyonder adopts a human form inspired by Captain America. This connection offers a compelling in-universe justification for Evans' casting. Imagine the layered impact of Evans playing a being who deliberately emulates the MCU's most iconic hero, only to reveal a very different personality and agenda.

Rumors of Judgment Day and Secret Wars happening on Battleworld add more weight to this theory. If Battleworld serves as the central arena for multiversal conflicts, the Beyonder's presence seems a natural fit. Marvel could reinvent the character's motivations and aesthetic while maintaining his reality-bending powers and his obsession with humanity. This reinvention would align with the studio's tendency to modernize its cosmic entities, as seen with Ego in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 and He who remains in Loki.

Why Beyonder is the perfect role for Chris Evans' MCU return

The Beyonder represents an exciting opportunity for Chris Evans to flex his acting muscles in a way audiences have never seen before. Unlike the grounded and morally centered Steve Rogers, the Beyonder is a extravagant, enigmatic and often morally ambiguous character. This would allow Evans to shed his serious persona and embrace a role that requires charm, eccentricity and unpredictability.

The Beyonder's comic origins are notoriously complicated, ranging from a living embodiment of an entire multiverse to a mutated Inhuman hybrid. This lack of rigid definition gives Marvel Studios the creative freedom to adapt the character specifically for Evans. They could lean on his charismatic screen presence while adding layers of complexity and menace. The Beyonder could swing between a surprisingly friendly facade and a chilling display of power, creating a dynamic that audiences can't take their eyes off of.

Casting Evans as the Beyonder adds an intriguing meta-commentary to the MCU. The Beyonder's fascination with humanity reflects the public's fascination with Evans as Captain America. His choice to model his appearance after Steve Rogers would blur the lines between character and actor, offering a poignant exploration of legacy and identity.

Imagine the dramatic tension if the Beyonder, with Evans' familiar face, manipulates the Avengers, forcing them to confront their own multiversal counterparts in the wake of RDJ's Doom. THE the character's playful yet menacing demeanor can make him a compelling foil for the team. This is particularly applicable to Sam Wilson's Captain America, who must assert himself in the shadow of Steve Rogers' Captain America.

Chris Evans' post-MCU roles have demonstrated his remarkable versatility. In Knives out, he abandoned his squeaky-clean image to play the smarmy and manipulative Ransom Drysdale. In The Gray Manhe embodied a psychotic antagonist with a disturbing mix of charm and menace. These performances prove that Evans can easily go from a sympathetic hero to a morally complex or outright villainous character.

As the Beyonder, Evans could draw on these experiences to create a performance that was equal parts captivating and unnerving. Whether the character is playing with the Avengers or struggling with his own existential crisis, Evans' the ability to convey depth and nuance would elevate the role. In fact, if Avengers: Judgment Day establishes the Beyonder as a key antagonist, Evans' star power could anchor the narrative leading up to Secret Wars.

The Beyonder's omnipotence and curiosity about human nature make him an ideal catalyst for the multiversal chaos that defines the plot. As the architect of Battleworld, the Beyonder's interactions with alternate versions of beloved characters would offer endless possibilities for drama and spectacle. Additionally, pairing Evans with other MCU heavyweights like Downey Jr.'s Doctor Doom would create a dynamic interplay of egos and ideologies, putting a villainous spin on their previous interactions to Avengers: Judgment Day.

• Release date

  February 14, 2025
  

• Rays*

• Release date

  July 25, 2025
  

• Release date

  July 24, 2026