Hunter x Hunter’s most controversial arc is actually the one that most deserves a movie, and there’s one simple reason

Hunter x Hunter is making a long-awaited comeback, and One arc needs a movie badly. The legendary manga is set to return to Shawn Jump After years of rest. This is just after the release of volume 38 in September 2024. With the series coming back into the public eye, Hunter x Hunter is sure to draw many new fans who want to work their way through its anime adaptations to begin their journey alongside Gon and Killua.

There are two big problems for the hopeful fans. First, there is the fact that Hunter x HunterThe latest anime isn’t set to return anytime soon, though the return of the manga could change that. There is also the fact that, despite two anime adaptations of Hunter x Hunter, The Greed Island arc never adapted well. Granted, after two attempts, it seems that Greed Island is simply a difficult arc to adapt, but there is reason to believe that a movie adaptation could fix this.

Hunter x Hunter’s Greed Island and the conflict with canon adaptations

Hunter x Hunter has the opportunity to take a nod from modern Sean

Greed Island is a sprawling arc where Gon and Killua enter a video game called, fittingly, Grid Island. The surreal premise is part of Gon’s overall mission to track down his father, one of the game’s creators. In the game, players are given binders in which they must place cards of varying rarity, and The objective of the game is to fill the binder.

Gon and Killua’s Greed Island adventures had a notable influence on the Isekai genre and also included some slick mechanics, like the materialization of cards into objects. New characters such as Biscuit also help bring the arc to life. However, as an anime adaptation, The gear plods and the stakes are too low to justify its running length– or, that is to say, as a faithful anime adaptation. Especially sandwiched between the highly regarded Yorknew City and Chimera Ant arcs, Greed Island absolutely kills the pacing of the anime, and things don’t have to be that way.

There may be value in doing the heresy: not being so faithful to Greed Island’s canon. Demon Slayer: Mugen Bane is a masterclass in how, without showing everything in the source material, it is possible to convey the feeling and emotional impact of the arc. The film and television adaptations of Demon SlayerMugen Train’s arc provides the basis for a fruitful discussion of how manga, television, and film all offer independent strengths to a source story. Lively discussions are still ongoing about which adaptation is better, and There’s no reason Grid Island shouldn’t be the basis for something similar.

A Greed Island movie would kill three animals with one stone

Adapting Hunter x Hunter’s Greed Island could test the waters while bringing the series to new fans

Of course, this is another side. It’s not just existing fans who would benefit from a shiny, new Grid Island adaptation. Since Grid Island is self-contained, it creates An opportunity for people who are curious about Hunter x Hunter to jump into. Hunter x Hunter Requires a significant commitment from the viewer, especially if they don’t get hooked right away. The Hunter Exam arc is great, but it’s also pretty basic by today’s standards.

The consensus in fan communities is that Hunter x Hunter Really comes into his own and picks up the pace with the New York City arc. A drop-in experience like a Greed Island film would allow people to watch Hunter x HunterS unique blend of the whimsical and diabolical and become attached to the series, helping with this commitment. A Greed Island film would also allow the franchise to test the waters with single arc adaptations. His success may even make it so More likely that the succession contest arc, once completed, will be adaptedWhether for television or film.

For those who want a 1:1 faithful experience, Grid Island already has two anime adaptations from two different eras. A film Capturing the spirit of Grid Island in a feature-length experience would let fans get the arc’s art without committing to skipping it or watching dozens of episodes of a battle-punctuated collect-a-thon. With the 2011 anime already intimidating in length, this would carry an obvious appeal. Hunter x Hunter Made history with Greed Island, but a selective adaptation that breathes life into it could be just what the series needs.